The Influence of Removing the Ten-Minute Bout Requirement on National Physical Activity Estimates
RESEARCH BRIEF — Volume 17 — February 27, 2020
Emily N. Ussery, PhD1; Kathleen B. Watson, PhD1; Susan A. Carlson, PhD1 (View author affiliations)
Suggested citation for this article: Ussery EN, Watson KB, Carlson SA. The Influence of Removing the Ten-Minute Bout Requirement on National Physical Activity Estimates. Prev Chronic Dis 2020;17:190321. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5888/pcd17.190321external icon.
What is already known on this topic?
Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans, 2nd edition, asserts that any duration of physical activity provides health benefits, removing the previous requirement that activity should be accumulated in bouts lasting 10 minutes or more.
What is added by this report?
Our report indicates that including short bouts (less than 10 min) of self-reported physical activity in total volume of self-reported physical activity has minimal impact on national physical activity estimates.
What are the implications for public health practice?
The updated guidelines might necessitate changes to definitions and measures used in public health surveillance. Our findings suggest the change in surveillance measures to accommodate the elimination of the 10-minute-bout requirement is unlikely to markedly influence national prevalence estimates obtained from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System or similar surveys.
The updated Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans (2nd edition) removes the requirement that physical activity should occur in bouts lasting 10 minutes or more to count toward the minimum aerobic guideline. Using self-reported data from the 2017 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (N = 386,960), we examined differences in national physical activity estimates with and without this requirement. Overall, 1.9% of adults reported activities in short bouts (<10 minutes). When excluding short bouts, 29.9% were inactive, 20.7% were insufficiently active, and 49.4% were active. When including short bouts, 29.1% were inactive, 21.4% were insufficiently active, and 49.5% were active. Eliminating the 10-minute-bout requirement had little effect on physical activity estimates.
The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans, 2nd edition, states that adults should perform at least 150 minutes per week of moderate-intensity aerobic physical activity or 75 minutes per week of vigorous-intensity physical activity, or an equivalent combination of both for substantial health benefits (1). Any duration of moderate to vigorous intensity physical activity (MVPA) contributes to this goal, removing the previous requirement that physical activity must be accumulated in bouts of at least 10 minutes (2). Our goal was to examine how incorporating this change into surveillance measures might influence national estimates of physical activity levels. We used data from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) to compare self-reported physical activity levels when short bouts were included or excluded from measures of total volume.
We used self-reported data from the 2017 BRFSS, a state-based telephone survey of noninstitutionalized US civilians aged 18 or older. BRFSS survey design and methodology are described elsewhere (3). Data were collected from 450,016 respondents in 50 states, Guam, Puerto Rico, and the District of Columbia. The median response rate for combined landline and cellular telephone respondents across states was 45.9% (range, 30.6%–64.1%).
Respondent characteristics were sex, age group (18–34, 35–49, 50–64, ≥65), race/ethnicity (non-Hispanic white, non-Hispanic black, Hispanic, non-Hispanic other, non-Hispanic multiracial), educational attainment (<high school graduate, high school graduate, some college, college graduate), and US Census region (Northeast, Midwest, South, West, US territories) (4). To assess physical activity, respondents reported the 2 nonoccupational, aerobic physical activities they spent the most time performing during the past month. For each activity, frequency (times per week or month) and bout duration (minutes or hours per bout) were reported. Each minute of vigorous-intensity physical activity was multiplied by 2, consistent with guidelines (1). Two measures of total physical activity volume were calculated according to the following guidelines: 1) minutes per week of MVPA, excluding bouts with reported duration less than 10 minutes or short bouts, according to the 2008 Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans (2), and 2) minutes per week of MVPA, including all reported bouts, as stated in the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans, 2nd edition (1). For each measure of volume, respondents were categorized as inactive (no MVPA with a bout duration of 10 minutes or more or no MVPA), insufficiently active (some MVPA but not meeting the active definition), or active (150 minutes or more per week of MVPA).
We estimated the prevalence of reporting at least 1 physical activity occurring in short bouts overall and by respondent characteristics (sex, age group, race/ethnicity, educational attainment, census region). Differences in prevalence across characteristics were tested by using corrected Pearson χ2 tests, with the significance level at .05. We also estimated the prevalence of each physical activity level (inactive, insufficiently active, active) by using both measures of volume overall and by respondent characteristics. Respondents with missing demographics (n = 10,169) or physical activity (n = 52,887) were excluded (analytic sample = 386,960). Analyses were conducted in Stata 13.1 (StataCorp LP) by using weights and SVY procedures to account for the complex sampling design of BRFSS.
Overall, 1.9% of US adults reported at least 1 of their most common physical activities occurred in short bouts (Table 1). Significant differences in prevalence were observed by sex, race/ethnicity, educational attainment, and census region (P < .05). Overall, 29.9% of adults were classified as physically inactive and 20.7% as insufficiently active when excluding short bouts, compared with 29.1% and 21.4% when including all bouts (Table 2). The prevalence of being active was similar when excluding or including short bouts (49.4% vs 49.5%). Comparable findings were observed across categories of sex, age group, race/ethnicity, educational attainment, and census region.
A small percentage of US adults reported physical activities occurring in short bouts. Moreover, including short bouts in measures of total physical activity volume did not result in meaningful differences in population-level physical activity levels, overall or across demographic groups. Our findings suggest a need to modify physical activity surveillance measures to remove the 10-minute bout requirement to align with recent guidelines, because the current measures used might have a minimal effect on national estimates of physical activity levels, particularly those obtained from BRFSS or similar surveys (1).
Our findings are inconsistent with those using device-based measures of physical activity. Studies using accelerometers found considerable variations in total volume of MVPA and adherence to guidelines when comparing activity accumulated in bouts of 10 minutes or more versus all accumulated activity (5,6). One possible explanation for the discrepancy is self-reported measures do not capture short bouts of physical activity as well as device-based measures because of the difficulty recalling short or unplanned episodes of physical activity (7). Moreover, the BRFSS questionnaire assesses average bout duration of respondents’ top 2 physical activities, whereas accelerometers capture individual bouts of activities.
Our study’s findings might not generalize to other surveillance systems that collect physical activity data. Although BRFSS captures physical activity that occurs in short bouts, 2 other major US surveillance systems exclude short bouts as part of their survey questions. In the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), respondents report physical activity performed for at least 10 minutes continuously (8). Similarly, the National Health Interview Survey (NHIS) asks about activities respondents perform for at least 10 minutes (9). The effects of removing the clause on physical activity estimates derived from NHANES or NHIS is unknown. Future studies can be undertaken to examine any potential effects more closely.
This study has limitations. First, BRFSS data are self-reported and could be subject to social desirability or recall biases. Second, respondents report only their top 2 nonoccupational physical activities. Thus, total physical activity, particularly activities occurring in short bouts, might be underestimated. Third, the median response rate was 45.9%; lower response rates could result in response bias, although BRFSS weighting and survey methodology are designed to adjust for nonresponse, noncoverage, and undercoverage issues (10). The study also had strengths, including the large national sample and data from the only US surveillance system that assesses short bouts of physical activity.
Accurate public health monitoring of behaviors relies on consistent definitions and measures over time; however, new guidelines can necessitate changes to how outcomes are defined and measured. Our findings suggest that removal of the 10-minute bout requirement to align with updated physical activity guidelines is unlikely to markedly influence national estimates of physical activity obtained from BRFSS or similar surveys.
No funding was obtained for this study. The authors have no financial relationships relevant to this study and no conflicts of interest to disclose. No copyrighted material or copyrighted surveys, instruments, or tools were used in this secondary data analysis. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Corresponding Author: Emily N. Ussery, PhD, Division of Nutrition, Physical Activity, and Obesity, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 4770 Buford Hwy NE, MS F77, Atlanta, GA 30341. Telephone: 770-488-3766. Email: email@example.com.
- US Department of Health and Human Services. Physical activity guidelines for Americans, 2nd edition. Washington (DC): US Department of Health and Human Services; 2018.
- US Department of Health and Human Services. Physical activity guidelines for Americans. Washington (DC): US Department of Health and Human Services; 2008.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Overview: Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System 2017. https://www.cdc.gov/brfss/annual_data/2017/pdf/overview-2017-508.pdf. Accessed January 8, 2020.
- US Census Bureau. 2010 Census regions and divisions of the United States. https://www.census.gov/geographies/reference-maps/2010/geo/2010-census-regions-and-divisions-of-the-united-states.html. Accessed January 8, 2020.
- Troiano RP, Berrigan D, Dodd KW, Masse LC, Tilert T, McDowell M. Physical activity in the United States measured by accelerometer. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2008;40(1):181–8.
- Orme M, Wijndaele K, Sharp SJ, Westgate K, Ekelund U, Brage S. Combined influence of epoch length, cut-point and bout duration on accelerometry-derived physical activity. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2014;11(1):34–42.
- Matthews CE, Moore SC, George SM, Sampson J, Bowles HR. Improving self-reports of active and sedentary behaviors in large epidemiologic studies. Exerc Sport Sci Rev 2012;40(3):118–26.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics. NHANES questionnaires, datasets, and related documentation. https://wwwn.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes. Accessed January 8, 2020.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics. NHIS questionnaires, datasets, and related documentation. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nhis/nhis_questionnaires.htm. Accessed January 9, 2020.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Methodologic changes in the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System in 2011 and potential effects on prevalence estimates. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2012;61(22):410–3.
|Characteristic||Sample Size Na||Reported Short Bouts||P Valuec|
|na||%b (95% CI)|
|Age group, y|
|Non-Hispanic white||298,919||5,359||1.9 (1.7–2.0)||.02|
|Non-Hispanic black||29,739||630||2.5 (2.0–2.9)|
|Non-Hispanic other||18,466||286||1.6 (1.0–2.2)|
|Non-Hispanic multiracial||8,049||159||1.9 (1.4–2.5)|
|Less than high school graduate||26,582||549||2.1 (1.7–2.4)||.02|
|High school graduate||103,462||1,909||2.0 (1.8–2.2)|
|Some college||108,003||1,930||2.0 (1.8–2.2)|
|College graduate||148,913||2,491||1.6 (1.5–1.7)|
|US territories||5,626||63||0.5 (0.3–0.8)|
|Characteristic||2008 Physical Activity Guidelinesb||Physical Activity Guidelines, 2nd Editionc|
|Inactive||Insufficiently Active||Active||Inactive||Insufficiently Active||Active|
|Overall||29.9 (29.6–30.3)||20.7 (20.4–21.0)||49.4 (49.0–49.7)||29.1 (28.8–29.4)||21.4 (21.1–21.7)||49.5 (49.1–49.8)|
|Male||28.5 (28.0–29.0)||20.8 (20.4–21.2)||50.7 (50.2–51.2)||27.6 (27.1–28.0)||21.6 (21.2–22.0)||50.8 (50.3–51.3)|
|Female||31.3 (30.9–31.7)||20.6 (20.2–21.0)||48.1 (47.6–48.6)||30.6 (30.2–31.0)||21.2 (20.8–21.6)||48.2 (47.7–48.7)|
|Age group, y|
|18–34||24.4 (23.8–25.0)||26.1 (25.5–26.7)||49.5 (48.8–50.2)||23.5 (22.8–24.1)||26.9 (26.3–27.6)||49.6 (48.9–50.3)|
|35–49||29.5 (28.8–30.2)||23.0 (22.4–23.6)||47.5 (46.7–48.2)||28.7 (28.0–29.4)||23.7 (23.1–24.3)||47.6 (46.9–48.3)|
|50−64||32.2 (31.6–32.8)||19.1 (18.6–19.6)||48.7 (48.1–49.4)||31.4 (30.8–32.0)||19.7 (19.2–20.2)||48.9 (48.2–49.5)|
|≥65||35.7 (35.1–36.3)||12.1 (11.7–12.5)||52.2 (51.5–52.8)||35.0 (34.4–35.6)||12.7 (12.3–13.1)||52.3 (51.7–53.0)|
|Non-Hispanic white||27.7 (27.4–28.1)||19.8 (19.5–20.1)||52.5 (52.1–52.8)||27.0 (26.7–27.3)||20.4 (20.1–20.7)||52.6 (52.2–53.0)|
|Non-Hispanic black||36.4 (35.4–37.5)||20.7 (19.8–21.6)||42.8 (41.7–43.9)||35.2 (34.2–36.3)||21.8 (20.8–22.7)||43.0 (41.9–44.1)|
|Hispanic||36.3 (35.2–37.3)||22.3 (21.3–23.2)||41.5 (40.4–42.6)||35.3 (34.3–36.4)||23.1 (22.2–24.1)||41.5 (40.5–42.6)|
|Non-Hispanic other||25.3 (23.7–26.9)||25.6 (23.9–27.2)||49.1 (47.3–51.0)||24.5 (22.9–26.1)||26.2 (24.5–27.8)||49.3 (47.5–51.2)|
|Non-Hispanic multiracial||26.6 (24.7–28.4)||19.4 (17.7–21.2)||54.0 (51.8–56.3)||26.0 (24.2–27.8)||19.9 (18.1–21.7)||54.1 (51.9–56.3)|
|Less than high school graduate||47.0 (45.8–48.1)||17.3 (16.4–18.3)||35.7 (34.6–36.9)||45.9 (44.7–47.1)||18.3 (17.4–19.3)||35.8 (34.6–36.9)|
|High school graduate||36.6 (35.9–37.2)||18.6 (18.1–19.2)||44.8 (44.1–45.4)||35.7 (35.0–36.3)||19.5 (18.9–20.0)||44.8 (44.2–45.5)|
|Some college||27.9 (27.3–28.5)||20.9 (20.4–21.5)||51.2 (50.5–51.8)||27.1 (26.5–27.7)||21.5 (21.0–22.1)||51.4 (50.7–52.0)|
|College graduate||17.9 (17.5–18.3)||24.0 (23.5–24.4)||58.1 (57.6–58.7)||17.3 (16.9–17.7)||24.5 (24.0–24.9)||58.2 (57.7–58.8)|
|Northeast||29.6 (28.9–30.2)||20.1 (19.6–20.7)||50.3 (49.6–51.0)||28.5 (27.8–29.2)||21.1 (20.5–21.7)||50.4 (49.7–51.1)|
|Midwest||29.3 (28.8–29.8)||21.2 (20.8–21.7)||49.5 (49.0–50.0)||28.7 (28.2–29.2)||21.7 (21.2–22.1)||49.6 (49.1–50.1)|
|South||33.7 (33.1–34.3)||20.5 (20.0–21.0)||45.8 (45.2–46.5)||32.6 (32.0–33.2)||21.4 (20.9–22.0)||46.0 (45.4–46.6)|
|West||23.4 (22.7–24.0)||20.8 (20.1–21.5)||55.9 (55.1–56.7)||23.0 (22.3–23.7)||21.0 (20.3–21.7)||56.0 (55.1–56.8)|
|US territories||55.7 (53.8–57.5)||24.2 (22.6–25.8)||20.1 (18.6–21.6)||55.3 (53.4–57.2)||24.6 (23.0–26.2)||20.1 (18.6–21.6)|
The opinions expressed by authors contributing to this journal do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the Public Health Service, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, or the authors’ affiliated institutions.