Skip directly to local search Skip directly to A to Z list Skip directly to navigation Skip directly to site content Skip directly to page options
CDC Home

Bethlehem Steel

(Site Profile/Docket Number 011)

Location: Lackawanna, New York

Special Exposure Cohort Petition Information

The Special Exposure Cohort (SEC) is a unique category of employees established by the Act (42 CFR Part 83). Claims compensated under the SEC do not have to go through the dose reconstruction process. To qualify for compensation under the SEC, a covered employee must meet specific requirements (e.g., must have at least one of 22 "specified cancers," and have worked for a specified time period at one of the SEC sites). Classes of employees and work sites can be considered for addition to the SEC through a NIOSH petition process. More information about the Special Exposure Cohort can be found on our Frequently Asked Questions page.

Open/Active SEC Petitions

To date, there are no open/active SEC petitions from Bethlehem Steel.

Classes Added to the SEC

  • All Atomic Weapons Employer employees who worked at the Bethlehem Steel Corporation facility in Lackawanna, New York from January 1, 1949 to December 31, 1952, for a number of work days aggregating at least 250 work days, occurring either solely under this employment or in combination with work days within the parameters established for one or more other classes of employees in the Special Exposure Cohort.

SEC Petitions Not Qualifying for Evaluation

  • Two separate petitions were received but did not qualify for evaluation because one petition did not meet the minimum petition requirements and the other petition was withdrawn by the applicant.

Petitions Qualified for Evaluation

Below is a list of the petitions that qualified for evaluation. Select a petition on the list to view the table for that particular petition.

Petitions

Petition 56Jan 1, 1949 to Dec 31, 1952

Petition 56
Steps in Petition Process: Petition Details:

Date Received

March 13, 2006

Date Qualified for Evaluation

August 29, 2006

Summary of Information in Petition

Location: 10 inch Bar Mill and Blooming Mill

Job Titles and/or Job Duties: Millwrights, welders, electricians, bricklayers, carpenters, all maintenance, testers, rollers, supervisors, crane operators, hookers, clean-up crews, grinders

Period of Employment: 1949 through 1952

Copy of the Petition Received

Bethlehem Steel Corporation SEC Petition [4.1 MB (10 pages)] March 13, 2006

Petition Attachments:

Federal Register Notice Announcing that the Bethlehem Steel Corporation SEC Petition has met the Minimum Qualifications for Review and Evaluation

September 7, 2006 [79 KB (1 page)]

SEC Petition Evaluation Report

February 21, 2007 [202 KB (53 pages)]

Evaluation Report Sent to the Advisory Board

February 22, 2007

Petition Discussed by the Advisory Board

The petition was discussed by the Advisory Board on May 20, 2010; May 3, 2007; July 18, 2007; January 9, 2008; and April 9, 2008, during its regular meetings.

Advisory Board Recommendation on SEC Petition

June 11, 2010 [34 KB (2 pages)]

HHS Letters to Congress Regarding the SEC Petition

June 14, 2010 [108 KB (11 pages)]

HHS Designation of Additional Members to the SEC

July 14, 2010 [48 KB (6 pages)]

Federal Register Notice: Designation of a Class of Employees for Addition to the Special Exposure Cohort

July 30, 2010 [69 KB (1 page)]

Effective Date for the SEC Class

August 13, 2010

Federal Register Notice: Final Effect of Designation of a Class of Employees for Addition to the Special Exposure Cohort

August 23, 2010 [67 KB (1 page)]

Letter to DOL Regarding the Addition of a New Class of Employees to the SEC

August 24, 2010 [29 KB (1 page)]

Worker Outreach Activities

Based on a recommendation from the Advisory Board to provide workers and site experts with opportunities to participate in developing the technical documents used in dose reconstruction, NIOSH established a Worker Outreach Program.

At Worker Outreach Meetings, current and former DOE and AWE employees have opportunities to obtain information about Site Profiles, Technical Basis Documents, and Technical Information Bulletins, and to provide information for consideration and possible use in dose reconstruction. This process is valuable to ensure that the technical documents used in dose reconstruction contain correct and useful information.

Worker Outreach Activities for the Bethlehem Steel:

Advisory Board Work Group on Bethlehem Steel

This Work Group is responsible for a review of the Bethlehem Steel Site Profile and a review of the Site Profile by the Board's contractor (SC&A). The Work Group shall consider issues identified by SC&A concerning the Site Profile and shall assist NIOSH and SC&A in the resolution of such issues. The Work Group may recommend to the Board changes in the Site Profile as appropriate.

Work Group Members:

  • James Malcolm Melius, M.D., Dr. P.H. (Chair)
  • Josie Beach
  • Mark Griffon
  • James E. Lockey, M.D., M.S.
  • Wanda I. Munn

Meeting Information

  • May 13, 2010 Teleconference Meeting of the Advisory Board's Work Group on the Use of Surrogate Data

    Time/Location:

    1:00 p.m. Eastern Standard Time (EST)
    Meeting Type: Teleconference; Public, No Comment Period

    Teleconference: +1-866-659-0537
    Participant Code: 9933701

    Available Meeting Items:

  • November 16, 2007 Teleconference Meeting of the Advisory Board's Work Group on the Use of Surrogate Data

    Time/Location:

    2:00 p.m. Eastern Standard Time (EST)
    Meeting Type: Teleconference; Public, No Comment Period

    Teleconference: +1-866-659-0537
    Participant Code: 9933701

    Available Meeting Items:

Technical Documents

If the energy employee's personal radiation information is incomplete, NIOSH will use other sources to estimate the radiation dose. This may involve using technical documents called Site Profiles, Technical Basis Documents, and Technical Information Bulletins.

Technical Basis Documents

  • Basis for Development of an Exposure Matrix for Bethlehem Steel [364 KB (34 pages)] Revised November 30, 2010

    Revision Includes: Incorporates SEC designation information; additional changes include deletion of unnecessary information throughout document affected by SEC; added information regarding recycled uranium at BSC and additional rolling data to Table 1; corrected minor typographical errors; included NIOSH internal comments.

Advisory Board and NIOSH Discussions on Bethlehem Steel

The Bethlehem Steel Corporation discussion papers listed below are working documents prepared by NIOSH or its contractor for use in discussions with the Advisory Board on Radiation and Worker Health or its Working Groups or Subcommittees. Draft, preliminary, interim, and white paper documents are not final NIOSH or Advisory Board (or their technical support and review contractors) positions unless specifically marked as such. These documents represent preliminary positions taken on technical issues prepared by NIOSH or its contractor.

The discussion papers have been reviewed to identify and redact any information that is protected by the Privacy Act 5 USC §552a and have been cleared for distribution.

Program Evaluation Reports (PERs) and Program Evaluation Plans (PEPs)

NIOSH is committed to applying the best available science in dose reconstructions. In keeping with this commitment, completed cases with probabilities of causation less than 50% are reviewed as relevant new information becomes available. The results of these reviews are described in a Program Evaluation Report (PER). The PER details the effect, if any, of the new information on the completed dose reconstruction. If it appears that the new information may result in an increase in dose for a completed dose reconstruction with a probability of causation of less than 50%, NIOSH is committed to working with the Department of Labor to reopen and rework the dose reconstruction, as appropriate. A Program Evaluation Plan (PEP) describes plans for evaluating specific program details or issues.

  • OCAS-PER-0003 Rev-00: Evaluation of the Effect of Adding Ingestion Intakes to Bethlehem Steel Cases [31 KB (3 pages)]

    January 28, 2005

    About this Document: Describes the evaluation of the programmatic effect of the effect of adding ingestion intakes to Bethlehem Steel cases.

    Summary: As a result of adding ingestion intakes, the probability of causation of none of the previously completed Bethlehem Steel claims would increase to greater than 50%.

  • OCAS-PER-0007 Rev-00: Evaluation of the Effect of Revision 2 of the Site Profile on Previously Completed Bethlehem Steel Cases [42 KB (7 pages)]

    November 9, 2006

    About this Document: New document to evaluate the effect of revision 2 of the Site Profile on previously completed dose reconstructions from Bethlehem Steel.

    Summary: The Bethlehem Steel Technical Basis Document was revised on July 27, 2006. The revision changed the estimated quantity of uranium inhaled and ingested as well as external dose to the skin. As a result of revisions to the Bethlehem Steel Technical Basis Document, three claims that were previously determined to have a PC of less than 50% will now have a PC greater than 50%. Eight cases that previously had a PC greater than 50% now have a PC less than 50%. This report, along with detailed information on the specific cases and calculations, has been provided to DOL for determination of further action.

Public Comments on Bethlehem Steel Documents

How to Submit Comments

Comments on Bethlehem Steel Documents can be submitted to the NIOSH Docket Officer electronically by email at nioshdocket@cdc.gov or printed comments can be mailed to:

NIOSH Docket Office
Robert A. Taft Laboratories, MS-C34
1090 Tusculum Avenue
Cincinnati, OH 45226

Please include the Site Profile/Docket Number (011) on all comments.

Comments Received:

Document Archive for Bethlehem Steel

  • Basis for Development of an Exposure Matrix for Bethlehem Steel Corporation
    • Site Profile for the Bethlehem Steel [618 KB (41 pages)]

      Revision Includes: Approved issue of Revision 0 of OCAS-TKBS-003. This supersedes rev. 1 of the previous ORAUT-TBKS-0001.

      An Exposure Matrix indicates the type and quantity of radiation exposure to individuals for a specific location and specific time. Locations can be as broad as an entire facility or as narrow as a single small room. Time can be years, months, or even a single event. When personnel monitoring data are incomplete or do not exist, an exposure matrix is developed to estimate the dose. The matrix is typically developed using a combination of personnel monitoring data in conjunction with area monitoring data. Once the exposure is estimated, data about how long the worker was exposed (time) is used to estimate their total exposure.

      There was no identified documentation that contained personal monitoring data for employees of the Bethlehem Steel site. Therefore, an exposure matrix that relied on air sampling data was developed to estimate radiation dose to many individuals. The matrix that was developed can be used to estimate the dose for a large number of the employees at the Bethlehem Steel site.

      In many cases, the development of a facility specific matrix is more difficult but due to the limited operations that took place in this AWE, this matrix was able to be developed more quickly. The following documented facts were used in the development of this matrix:

      • Uranium processing occurred on one rolling mill.
      • The amount of time involving work with uranium was no more than 500 hours total over a four year period.

      Because of these two facts, the workplace exposure conditions could be estimated from the available data. Once the workplace exposures were estimated, Bethlehem Steel employees are then assumed to be exposed to these "worst-case scenario" conditions as a claimant favorable approach.

    • Revised June 29, 2004 [150 KB (13 pages)]

      Revision Includes: Revision to incorporate occupational X-ray doses from the OTIB-0006, estimates of ingestion intakes, and additional OCAS comments.

    • Approved March 31, 2003 [149 KB (14 pages)]
 
Contact DCAS:
Contact Us:
USA.gov: The U.S. Government's Official Web PortalDepartment of Health and Human Services
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention   1600 Clifton Road Atlanta, GA 30329-4027, USA
800-CDC-INFO (800-232-4636) TTY: (888) 232-6348 - Contact CDC–INFO