2016–2018 One Health Harmful Algal Bloom System (OHHABS) Report: Supplemental Tables and Figures

These tables and figures provide supplemental information not published in Surveillance for harmful algal bloom events and associated human and animal illnesses—One Health Harmful Algal Bloom System, United States, 2016-2018 (MMWR Weekly).

Note: To save these images, left-click, hold, and drag each image to the folder where you want to save it.

OHHABS Development
OHHABS Working Group

State and federal partners in the OHHABS Working Group from 2014 to 2016 informed development of the reporting system. State partners included Arizona, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, Ohio, Oregon, South Carolina, Virginia, Washington, and Wisconsin. Federal partners included the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR), National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), National Park Service (NPS), U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), and United States Geological Survey (USGS), with support from the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative (GLRI).

OHHABS Map working groups for 2014-2016 with state partners, and federal partner logos including the EPA, NOAA, ATSDR, USGS, FDA, Great Lakes Restoration, and the National Parks Service.
OHHABS development timeline

CDC and partners began development of the system in 2014 and launched the system nationally in 2016. The OHHABS Working Group was formed in January 2014, with IT development beginning in March. In May 2015, CDC finalized the definitions used to classify harmful algal bloom (HAB) events and associated cases of illness in OHHABS. The system was piloted in August 2015 before the official launch in June 2016.

2014–2016 OHHABS development timeline. In January 2014, OHHABS Working Group initiated. In March 20014, IT Development began. In May 2015, case and event definitions were finalized. In August 2015, OHHABS pilot launched. In June 2016, OHHABS launched.
HAB Events and Cases
States reporting HAB events

A total of 18 states adopted OHHABS and voluntarily reported 421 HAB events during 2016–2018: Alaska, Arizona, California, Connecticut, Florida, Kansas, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Utah, Virginia, Wisconsin.

Thirteen states reported human cases, animal cases, or both: Alaska, California, Florida, Kansas, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Utah, Virginia, Wisconsin.

Ten states reported human cases: Alaska, California, Kansas, Minnesota, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Utah, Wisconsin.

Ten state reported animal cases: California, Florida, Kansas, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, Oregon, Utah, Virginia, Wisconsin.

Map of the United States showing the 18 states that reported to OHHABS during 2016 to 2018.
Reported HAB events with associated human and animal cases

States submitted 421 HAB event reports into OHHABS for 2016–2018, including 312 HAB events that did not have any associated cases. There were 73 HAB events with associated human cases, 42 with associated animal cases, and 6 with associated human and animal cases. There were 389 cases of human illnesses and at least 413 cases of animal illnesses associated with reported HAB events. The cases of animal illness were reported as 55 single cases of illness, as well as nine groups of illness. The nine groups accounted for at least 358 animal illnesses.

Figure showing reported HAB events (n-421) with associated human (n=73) and animal cases (n=42)
Reported HAB events and cases by month, 2016–2018

Two separate HAB events produced peaks of human and animal cases, as seen in this figure. During July 2016, a large HAB event resulted in 199 human cases, and in May 2018 a large HAB event caused a die-off of 300 birds.

HAB event month was assigned based on available data, using the following hierarchy: 1) bloom observation date, 2) month of bloom notification, 3) earliest date of an associated human or animal case.

Human case month is the reported illness onset date. Animal cases were assigned months based on available data, using the following hierarchy: 1) illness onset date, 2) discovery date, 3) death date.

Graph of reported HAB events and cases by month. Animal cases spiked in May, human cases spiked in July, and HAB events spiked in July.
Animal cases reported to OHHABS by month, 2016–2018

In May 2018, a bloom event resulted in a large bird die-off of 300 individuals. Animal cases were assigned months based on available data, using the following hierarchy: 1) illness onset date, 2) discovery date, 3) death date.

Graph showing reported HAB event and case occurrence by month; HABs occurred May to November, with domestic animal cases spiking in July, wildlife animal cases spiking in May, and livestock animal cases spiking in June.
Classification of reported HAB events and associated cases, 2016–2018

HAB events could be classified as either suspected or confirmed; HAB-associated cases of illness could be classified as either suspected, probable, or confirmed. The majority (88%) of the 421 reported HAB events were confirmed. The majority (88%) of the 389 reported human cases were probable. The majority (81%) of 413 reported animal cases were suspected. Case classification criteria are provided in the HAB event and case definitions [PDF – 3 pages].

Graph of HAB event and case classification; most HAB events were confirmed (n=370), human cases probable (n=341), and animal cases suspected (n=333).
Classification of reported HAB-associated animal cases, by type, 2016–2018

HAB-associated animal cases of illness could be classified as either suspected, probable, or confirmed. The majority (99%) of 319 reported wildlife cases were suspected. The majority (60%) of the 52 reported domestic pet cases were probable. The majority (81%) of the 42 reported livestock cases were probable. Case classification criteria are located in the HAB event and case definitions [PDF – 3 pages].

Graph of animal case classification; most wildlife cases were suspected (n=317), and most pet (n=31) and livestock (n=34) cases were probable.
Human Signs and Symptoms

Reported signs and symptoms in 389 human cases of HAB-associated illness during 2016–2018 were classified primarily based on the organ system affected. “Generalized” refers to constitutional signs and symptoms such as headache, fever, or lethargy. Some signs and symptoms classified as neurologic may present in other systems (e.g., ophthalmologic). Gastrointestinal, generalized, and dermatologic were the most frequently reported categories.

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

n (%)§

n (%)§

n (%)§

Cardiopulmonary

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Cardiopulmonary

41 (11)

n (%)§

41 (11)

Cough

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Cough

18 (5)

n (%)§

18 (5)

Dyspnea (shortness of breath)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Dyspnea (shortness of breath)

16 (4)

n (%)§

16 (4)

Difficulty breathing

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Difficulty breathing

8 (2)

n (%)§

8 (2)

Chest tightness

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Chest tightness

4 (1)

n (%)§

4 (1)

Chest pain

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Chest pain

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Respiratory symptoms (nonspecific)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Respiratory symptoms (nonspecific)

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Respiratory irritation

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Respiratory irritation

1 (<1)

n (%)§

1 (<1)

Wheezing

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Wheezing

1 (<1)

n (%)§

1 (<1)

Tachycardia (rapid heartbeat)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Tachycardia (rapid heartbeat)

1 (<1)

n (%)§

1 (<1)

Dermatologic

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Dermatologic

104 (27)

n (%)§

104 (27)

Rash

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Rash

57 (15)

n (%)§

57 (15)

Pruritus (itchy skin)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Pruritus (itchy skin)

32 (8)

n (%)§

32 (8)

Erythema (redness)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Erythema (redness)

8 (2)

n (%)§

8 (2)

Irritated skin

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Irritated skin

8 (2)

n (%)§

8 (2)

Skin burning/pain

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Skin burning/pain

7 (2)

n (%)§

7 (2)

Infected wound

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Infected wound

4 (1)

n (%)§

4 (1)

Skin blisters

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Skin blisters

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Itchy welts

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Itchy welts

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Bullous skin lesions (fluid filled blisters)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Bullous skin lesions (fluid filled blisters)

2 (1)

n (%)§

2 (1)

Skin infection

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Skin infection

1 (<1)

n (%)§

1 (<1)

Urticaria (hives)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Urticaria (hives)

1 (<1)

n (%)§

1 (<1)

Ear/Nose/Throat

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Ear/Nose/Throat

62 (16)

n (%)§

62 (16)

Throat, sore or pain

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Throat, sore or pain

29 (7)

n (%)§

29 (7)

Nasal, congestion (rhinitis)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Nasal, congestion (rhinitis)

19 (5)

n (%)§

19 (5)

Throat, irritation

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Throat, irritation

12 (3)

n (%)§

12 (3)

Nasal, coryza (runny nose)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Nasal, coryza (runny nose)

9 (2)

n (%)§

9 (2)

Ears, ache or pain

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Ears, ache or pain

4 (1)

n (%)§

4 (1)

Sneezing

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Sneezing

4 (1)

n (%)§

4 (1)

Oral, sores

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Oral, sores

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Oral, numbness

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Oral, numbness

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Oral, swelling

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Oral, swelling

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Tongue, swollen

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Tongue, swollen

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Nasal inflammation

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Nasal inflammation

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Dysphasia (difficulty swallowing)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Dysphasia (difficulty swallowing)

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Gastrointestinal

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Gastrointestinal

262 (69)

n (%)§

262 (69)

Diarrhea

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Diarrhea

153 (39)

n (%)§

153 (39)

Nausea

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Nausea

139 (36)

n (%)§

139 (36)

Vomiting

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Vomiting

116 (30)

n (%)§

116 (30)

Abdominal pain (tenderness)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Abdominal pain (tenderness)

75 (19)

n (%)§

75 (19)

Abdominal cramps

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Abdominal cramps

27 (7)

n (%)§

27 (7)

Bloody stools

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Bloody stools

4 (1)

n (%)§

4 (1)

Gas/bloating

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Gas/bloating

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Generalized

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Generalized

169 (43)

n (%)§

169 (43)

Headache

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Headache

105 (27)

n (%)§

105 (27)

Fever

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Fever

51 (13)

n (%)§

51 (13)

Fatigue

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Fatigue

29 (7)

n (%)§

29 (7)

Anorexia (loss of appetite)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Anorexia (loss of appetite)

16 (4)

n (%)§

16 (4)

Lethargy (lack of energy, tiredness)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Lethargy (lack of energy, tiredness)

16 (4)

n (%)§

16 (4)

Chills

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Chills

13 (3)

n (%)§

13 (3)

Pain (general)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Pain (general)

10 (3)

n (%)§

10 (3)

Body ache

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Body ache

8 (2)

n (%)§

8 (2)

Malaise (general discomfort)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Malaise (general discomfort)

7 (2)

n (%)§

7 (2)

Night sweats

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Night sweats

5 (1)

n (%)§

5 (1)

Faintness (lightheadedness)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Faintness (lightheadedness)

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Pallor

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Pallor

2 (1)

n (%)§

2 (1)

Hot flash(es)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Hot flash(es)

2 (1)

n (%)§

2 (1)

Flushing (face or body)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Flushing (face or body)

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Sweating

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Sweating

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Flu-like symptoms

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Flu-like symptoms

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Genitourinary

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Genitourinary

6 (2)

n (%)§

6 (2)

Dysuria (pain with urination)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Dysuria (pain with urination)

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Dark urine

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Dark urine

2 (1)

n (%)§

2 (1)

Hematuria (blood in urine)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Hematuria (blood in urine)

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Musculoskeletal

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Musculoskeletal

13 (3)

n (%)§

13 (3)

Muscle pain

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Muscle pain

10 (3)

n (%)§

10 (3)

Arthralgia (joint pain)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Arthralgia (joint pain)

5 (1)

n (%)§

5 (1)

Muscle fatigue

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Muscle fatigue

2 (1)

n (%)§

2 (1)

Backache

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Backache

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Muscle cramps

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Muscle cramps

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Neurologic

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Neurologic

56 (14)

n (%)§

56 (14)

Dizziness

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Dizziness

34 (9)

n (%)§

34 (9)

Paresthesia (tingling sensation)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Paresthesia (tingling sensation)

17 (4)

n (%)§

17 (4)

Weakness

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Weakness

15 (4)

n (%)§

15 (4)

Ataxia (loss of coordination)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Ataxia (loss of coordination)

5 (1)

n (%)§

5 (1)

Temperature reversal (hot-cold reversal)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Temperature reversal (hot-cold reversal)

5 (1)

n (%)§

5 (1)

Confusion

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Confusion

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Neurological symptoms (nonspecific)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Neurological symptoms (nonspecific)

2 (1)

n (%)§

2 (1)

Seizures

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Seizures

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Ascending paralysis

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Ascending paralysis

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Ophthalmologic

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Ophthalmologic

30 (8)

n (%)§

30 (8)

Eye irritation

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Eye irritation

14 (4)

n (%)§

14 (4)

Blurred vision

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Blurred vision

5 (1)

n (%)§

5 (1)

Eye burning

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Eye burning

4 (1)

n (%)§

4 (1)

Conjunctivitis (pinkeye)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Conjunctivitis (pinkeye)

4 (1)

n (%)§

4 (1)

Periorbital edema (swelling)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Periorbital edema (swelling)

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Eye pain

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Eye pain

3 (1)

n (%)§

3 (1)

Eye redness

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Eye redness

2 (1)

n (%)§

2 (1)

Watery eyes

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Watery eyes

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Eye symptoms (nonspecific)

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Eye symptoms (nonspecific)

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Other

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Other

30 (8)

n (%)§

30 (8)

Other

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Other

28 (7)

n (%)§

28 (7)

Dry mouth

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Dry mouth

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Anaphylaxis

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Anaphylaxis

1(<1)

n (%)§

1(<1)

Unknown

Human Signs and Symptoms (n=389 cases)*

Unknown

9 (2)

n (%)§

9 (2)

67% of cases still experienced symptoms at the time of interview.

§ Percentages may exceed 100% because multiple options could be selected.

Includes one report of hematemesis (bloody vomitus).

Animal Signs

Reported signs in 92 animal cases of HAB-associated illness during 2016–2018 were classified primarily based on the organ system affected. “Generalized” refers to constitutional signs such as weakness, lethargy, or anorexia. Some signs classified as neurologic may present in other systems (e.g., ophthalmologic).

Animal Signs*

Animal Signs*

Animal Signs*

n (%)§

n (%)§

n (%)§

Cardiopulmonary

Animal Signs*

Cardiopulmonary

7 (8)

n (%)§

7 (8)

Shock

Animal Signs*

Shock

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Hypotension

Animal Signs*

Hypotension

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Labored breathing

Animal Signs*

Labored breathing

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Wheezing

Animal Signs*

Wheezing

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Cyanosis/pale mucous membrane

Animal Signs*

Cyanosis/pale mucous membrane

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Respiratory arrest

Animal Signs*

Respiratory arrest

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Dermatologic

Animal Signs*

Dermatologic

2 (2)

n (%)§

2 (2)

Itching

Animal Signs*

Itching

2 (2)

n (%)§

2 (2)

Ear/Nose/Throat

Animal Signs*

Ear/Nose/Throat

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Ear irritation

Animal Signs*

Ear irritation

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Gastrointestinal

Animal Signs*

Gastrointestinal

50 (54)

n (%)§

50 (54)

Diarrhea

Animal Signs*

Diarrhea

26 (28)

n (%)§

26 (28)

Vomiting

Animal Signs*

Vomiting

24 (26)

n (%)§

24 (26)

Liver failure

Animal Signs*

Liver failure

2 (2)

n (%)§

2 (2)

Painful abdomen (on palpitation)

Animal Signs*

Painful abdomen (on palpitation)

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Jaundice

Animal Signs*

Jaundice

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Tucked abdomen (arched back)

Animal Signs*

Tucked abdomen (arched back)

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Generalized

Animal Signs*

Generalized

59 (64)

n (%)§

59 (64)

Lethargy

Animal Signs*

Lethargy

15 (16)

n (%)§

15 (16)

Anorexia (loss of appetite)

Animal Signs*

Anorexia (loss of appetite)

10 (11)

n (%)§

10 (11)

Weakness

Animal Signs*

Weakness

6 (7)

n (%)§

6 (7)

Collapse (unable to stand)

Animal Signs*

Collapse (unable to stand)

4 (4)

n (%)§

4 (4)

Dehydration (refusing water)

Animal Signs*

Dehydration (refusing water)

2 (2)

n (%)§

2 (2)

Stumbling

Animal Signs*

Stumbling

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Whining or abnormal vocalization

Animal Signs*

Whining or abnormal vocalization

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Hematologic

Animal Signs*

Hematologic

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Unexplained bleeding

Animal Signs*

Unexplained bleeding

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Neurologic

Animal Signs*

Neurologic

13 (14)

n (%)§

13 (14)

Seizure/Convulsions

Animal Signs*

Seizure/Convulsions

6 (7)

n (%)§

6 (7)

Ataxia (stumbling, loss of balance)

Animal Signs*

Ataxia (stumbling, loss of balance)

3 (3)

n (%)§

3 (3)

Behavior change

Animal Signs*

Behavior change

2 (2)

n (%)§

2 (2)

Paralysis

Animal Signs*

Paralysis

2 (2)

n (%)§

2 (2)

Opisthotonos (severe hyperextension)

Animal Signs*

Opisthotonos (severe hyperextension)

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Stupor (decreased consciousness, unresponsiveness)

Animal Signs*

Stupor (decreased consciousness, unresponsiveness)

1 (1)

n (%)§

1 (1)

Other

Animal Signs*

Other

3 (3)

n (%)§

3 (3)

Other

Animal Signs*

Other

3 (3)

n (%)§

3 (3)

 Summarized for the subset of reports with data available.

§ Percentages may exceed 100% because multiple options could be selected.