|
|
Prevention Of Contact
Dermatitis By European Legislation
Carola Lidén, professor, MD, PhD, Department of Occupational and Environmental
Dermatology, Stockholm County Council and Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm,
Sweden (Corresponding Author)
Legislation is an important
tool in primary and secondary prevention of contact dermatitis. There
are similarities and differences between the European and North American
legislations. A brief description will be given of the European system
and some examples of how exposure to major contact allergens has been
limited.
Classification of dangerous
substances and preparations
The EU Directives on classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous
substances (Directive 67/548/EEC and amendments) and preparations (Directive
88/379/EEC and amendments; from July 2002 substituted by Directive 1999/45/EC)
covers chemicals intended for both consumer and workplace use. Today,
approximately 500 substances are classified as skin sensiter. Classified
substances are listed in Annex I of Directive 67/548/EEC. The general
concentration limit for classification of preparations/products as skin
sensitiser is 1% (corresponding to “percentage cut-off”). Specific and
lower limits are increasingly used, and specific concentration limits
have been set for more than 30 substances. The lowest being 15 ppm for
the preservative MCI/MI. Preparations have to be labelled with the name
of the sensitiser and a risk phrase (R 43 “May cause sensitisation by
skin contact”). The new Dangerous Preparations Directive (1999/45/EC)
requires also that the packaging of products containing 0.1% or more of
a skin sensitiser must bear the inscription ”Contains ‘the name of sensitiser’.
Many produce an allergic reaction.”
In the EU, consumer products
are subject to the same classification and labelling procedure as for
workplace preparations. Safety Data Sheets have to be provided for professional
users.
Nickel
The EU Nickel Directive (Directive 94/27/EEC) entered into full force
in July 2001. Nickel is limited (1) in posts used during epithelization
after piercing (nickel content below 0.05%); (2) in objects intended for
direct and prolonged contact with the skin, such as jewellery, watches,
buttons, zippers etc. (nickel release below 0.5 microgram/cm2/week); and
(3) coated items under (2) must fulfil the criteria after ”two years of
normal use”. The Nickel Directive is based on three reference test methods,
CEN standards, for control of compliance with the requirements of the
directive. There are strong indications that nickel allergy is decreasing
in Denmark, where nickel has been limited for more than 10 years. The
market in Sweden had, already before the entry into force, started to
adapt to the requirements.
Cosmetics
The EU Cosmetics Directive (Directive 76/768/EEC, and amendments) covers
cosmetics and hygiene products and ingredients. The Directive requires
full ingredient identification by INCI names, with the exception that
perfumes are not fully identified. Negative, restrictive, and positive
lists control cosmetic ingredients. Several skin sensitisers are restricted
and some are prohibited by the directive.
Chrome(VI) in cement
National regulation in Nordic countries limits chrome(VI) in cement (below
2 mg/kg, by the addition of iron sulfate). A similar approach has been
proposed also on the European level. Cement, containing more than 2 mg/kg
chrome(VI), requires labelling in Europe from July 2002 (1999/45/EC, first
amendment) with the phrase "Contains chromium(VI). May produce an allergic
reaction".
Standardisation
European standardisation (CEN) may support European and national legislation
aiming at the prevention of contact dermatitis, such as the Nickel Directive.
A standardisation project (CEN BT/WG 132 ”Methods for analysis of allergens”)
is currently trying to identify also other areas where the development
of standardised analytical methods for specific allergens could support
existing or planned European legislation.
Active participation of experts
on contact dermatitis, including dermatologists, chemists, hygienists
and toxicologists is essential for the development of clinically relevant
regulations. Scientific studies should be performed to evaluate the effects
of legislation aiming at prevention of contact dermatitis.
|