|
|
Occupational
Environment and Skin Diseases in Pesticide Exposed Subjects in Some
Tea Farms in Vietnam
K Xuyen,
MD, PhD, National Institute of Occupational and Environmental Health,
Hanoi, Vietnam (Corresponding Author)
PC Hoi, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Hanoi, Vietnam
PQ Trung, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Hanoi, Vietnam
Generalities
Vietnam is an agricultural country, so pesticide is used more and more
for the prevention of insects and increase of rice productivity as well
as other industrial trees, such as rubber, coffee and tea.
According
to the investigations of the agricultural and health branch, at present,
the pesticides mostly used in Vietnam are organophosphates and carbamates
(85-96.8%). The cultivation area using pesticides in the 1960's was only
0.5% with the quantity under 100 tonnes yearly, but it increased up to
50% with 10000 tonnes a year in the 1980's, and in the early 1990's, the
cultivation area grew to 90% and pesticide use increased to 20000 tonnes
yearly.
Because
of broad pesticide use, Vietnam rice productivity increased from 10 million
tonnes yearly in the 1970's up to 30 million tonnes yearly, and Vietnam
has become one of the biggest rice exporters in the world.
Besides
the great effects of pesticide use, the hazard of environmental pollution
and the number of pesticide poisonings are increasing more and more. This
problem requires much attention.
The objectives of
the research work are as follows:
1- Investigation of the working environment and the health of workers
exposed to pesticides.
2- Evaluate the relationship between working environment and farmers'
health, especially the occupational skin diseases of pesticide-exposed
subjects.
Methods and
materials
1- Subjects:
- Some government
tea farms and some family tea farms.
- The subjects exposed to pesticides (mixing, spraying, storing
and picking off the tea leaves).
- The subjects non-exposed to pesticides (logistical staff, health
staff and workers who also work in the Tea farm but are not exposed
to pesticides).
- Quantity of subjects:
369 subjects exposed to pesticides.
150 subjects non-exposed to
pesticides |
2- Methods:
- Investigation
of the use of pesticides by questionnaire.
- Determination of pesticide concentration (organophosphates).
- Detection of the major signs and symptoms.
- Medical examination of
occupational skin diseases.
- Patch testing. |
Results
Table 1. The situation
of pesticides use:
|
No.
|
Pesticides
|
|
Family
Tea Farms
|
|
1
|
Organophosphates
(Monitor, Wofatox...)
|
1.45
kg/ha
|
1.80
kg/ha
|
|
2
|
Carbamates
(Bassa, Padan...)
|
2.13 kg/ha
|
2.28
kg/ha
|
|
3
|
Pyrethroides (Cidi, Politrin...)
|
0.38
kg/ha
|
0.25
kg/ha
|
|
4
|
Other kinds (organochlorides, fungicides...)
|
0.12
kg/ha
|
0.15
kg/ha
|
Table 2. Wofatox concentration
in the air:
|
No.
|
Workplaces
|
Government Tea Farms (mg/m3)
|
Family Tea Farms (mg/m3)
|
|
1
|
Head
of the wind
|
0
|
0
|
|
2
|
End
of the wind
|
0.62
|
1.01
|
|
|
Maximum Allowable
Concentration
|
0.1
mg/m3
|
Table 3. The major signs and symptoms:
|
No.
|
Symptoms and signs
|
Quantity
|
Percentage (%)
|
|
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
|
Tiredness
Headache
Nausea
Skin itch
Insomnia
Lacrimation
Saliva hypersecretion
Blurred vision
Cough
Dizziness
|
135
164
56
215
39
17
37
31
7
90
|
36.58
44.44
15.17
58.26
10.50
4.50
10.00
8.50
1.90
24.39
|
| Table 4. Skin disease forms: |
| |
- Medically
examined subjects
- Skin diseases
- Prevalence rate |
: 369
: 273
: 73.98% |
|
No.
|
Symptoms and signs
|
Quantity
|
Percentage (%)
|
|
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
|
Prurigo
Mycosis (nail, skin...)
Irritant dermatitis
Contact dermatitis
Contact eczema
Melanosis
Other dermatosis
|
215
51
48
30
12
33
57
|
58.26
13.82
13.20
8.13
3.25
8.94
15.44
|
Table 5. Comparison of dermatosis between groups directly and indirectly
exposed to pesticides:
|
Group
|
Skin diseases
|
No skin diseases
|
Total
|
|
Exposed
|
273
|
96
|
369
|
|
Non-exposed
|
8
|
142
|
150
|
OR = 16.06, 95%
CI = 8.32 - 31.64, p < 0.001
Table 6. Patch test (n=138):
138 subjects sensitive to pesticides were submitted to patch testing;
the positive reaction was 39.73%
|
No.
|
Allergens
|
Positive Reaction
|
Rate (%)
|
|
1
2
3
4
|
Padan
Wofatox
Monitor
Bi 58 |
12/138
6/138
21/138
15/138
|
8.70
4.35
15.20
10.90
|
|
|
Total
|
54/138
|
39.73%
|
Discussion
- At present, the pesticides mostly used in Vietnam are organophosphates
and carbamates (85-96.8%). The quantity of pesticides used by family tea
farms was more than by government tea farms.
- The concentration of wofatox was 6-10 times higher than Maximum Allowable
Concentration
- Almost all spraymen had such symptoms as prurigo (58.26 %), headache
(44.44 %), fatigue (36.58 %) and nausea (15.17 %).
- Work-related disease such as melanosis was 8.94 % and allergic contact
dermatitis in the pesticide-exposed group was 16 times higher than in
the non-exposed group and the difference between rates of diseases was
statistically significant (p < 0.001, OR = 16.06, 95% CI = 8.32-31.64).
- 138 subjects sensitive to pesticide were tested; the patch test positive
reaction was 39.73 %, and the strong reaction was 8.70 % (Padan). It showed
the cause of occupational skin diseases of pesticide subjects in tea farms
in Vietnam.
Conclusions
- Up to now
in Vietnam, the most frequently used pesticides are organophosphates and
carbamates.
- The skin disease rate of the subjects exposed to pesticide was very
high (73 %). The work-related disease such as allergic contact dermatitis
in the pesticide-exposed group was 16 times higher than in the non-exposed
group. It showed the cause and effect relationship between the working
environment and occupational skin diseases.
Recommendations
- To promote education on the safe use of pesticides on government and
family tea farms.
- The contacters' health needed proper concern and good protection.
References
1/ Nguyen duy Bao,
Nguyen huy Dan, Bui van Chung et al ., Evaluation of the air pollution
and health impacts due to the use of pesticides in agriculture, The 2nd
National Scientific Conference on Occupational health , 13-15 December
1995, Hanoi, Vietnam.
2/ Tran huy Tho,
The pesticides using in Tea farm branch. National wokshop on impact of
pesticides on Human heath in Viet nam, Hanoi, 27-28 April 1994 .
3/ Nguyen thi hong
Tu et al., Workshop on safe use of Pesticides, Hanoi, 29-30 August 1997.
4/ Le Trung et al.,
Workshop on the safe use of pesticides and on the dianosis and treatment
of pesticide poisoning, Hanoi, Vietnam, August, 1995.
5/ Khuc Xuyen, Le
tu Van, The dermatosis in Agricuture, pp 121 - 128, The Occupational Skin
Diseases (Book) Hanoi 1998
6/ Khuc Xuyen, Le
tu Van, The skin diseases due to pesticides, PP 129 - 134, The Occupational
Skin Diseases (Book), 1998.
7/ Bates, J.A.R.,
Safe practice in pesticide use, WHO regional office for Europe - Copenhagen
1982, pp 195 - 213.
8/ Coppleston, J-F
et al., Expose to pesticides in agriculture - A survey of spraymen using
dimethoate in Sudan (1976), Bulletin of the World Health Organization
54, pp 217 - 223.
9/ WHO. The WHO recommended
classification of pesticides by hazard and guidelines to classification
1990-1991, Unpublished WHO document WHO/PCS/90-I - 1211 Geneva 27, Switzerland,
1990.
10/ Robert M. Adams,
Occupational Skin Disease, pp 136 - 149, Grune & Tratton, Inc., 111
Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003, 1983.
|