NORA Manufacturing Sector Strategic Goals
R219492 - 021H: Evaluation of Policies and Procedures to Prevent Worker-on-Worker Violence (9492)Start Date: 9/1/2009
End Date: 8/31/2011
Principal Investigator (PI)Name: Bernadine Kuchinski
Funded By: NIOSH
Primary Goal Addressed
Secondary Goal Addressed
Attributed to Manufacturing
The investigators will work with the Threat Assessment Teams of Boeing Corporation to develop and evaluate the use of tabletop exercises based on their model policies and procedures. This company has been proactive in developing worker-on-worker violence policies and procedures and has one of the nation's model programs. The goal of tabletop exercises is to provide threat scenarios so that stakeholders can gain experience in applying policies and procedures, evaluate successes and failures, and identify methods to improve response. These exercises have been used extensively in the field of disaster preparedness and provide one of the best methods for testing protocols to respond to potential threats. The rationale for conducting this pilot study of a model worker-on-worker violence prevention program derives from the absence of any published literature that evaluates the effectiveness of such policies and procedures.
Because of the high financial and personal costs of worker-on-worker violence, businesses need to proactively prevent and respond to potential threats of violence. In order to do so, businesses must have policies and procedures for worker-on-worker violence. The objective of this R21 exploratory proposal is to determine if tabletop scenario exercises adapted from disaster preparedness research can serve as an effective tool to evaluate and improve business's policies and procedures for worker-on-worker violence. A tabletop scenario exercise is a participatory problem-solving session where communication and decision-making processes can be systematically evaluated while a team responds to a simulated threat scenario. Participants can gain experience in applying policies and procedures, while evaluation can measure areas of success and failure and identify methods to improve response. The study's specific aims are to: (1) determine if tabletop exercises can be effective tools to train employees in applying written policies and procedures, (2) determine if tabletop exercises can be effective tools to measure how written policies and procedures are implemented, and (3) determine if tabletop exercises can be used to identify gaps in and barriers to implementing written policies and procedures. We will work with the ten Threat Assessment Teams of one of the nation's largest companies, Boeing. Following a critical analysis of Boeing's existing policies and procedures and a review of responses to previous worker-on-worker violent events, we will design new tabletop scenarios that reflect the experiences of Boeing employees. We will then assess will how existing policies are applied by participants during the exercises. Our evaluation will include process, impact, and outcome components to identify how tabletop exercises can be used as a tool for both training and research. Tabletop scenario development and exercise evaluation will be derived from methods used by the Federal Emergency Management System and the Department of Homeland Security. Ultimately, we plan to use this information to propose a randomized study on the implementation and evaluation of worker-on-worker violence prevention policies and procedures in a variety of business types and sizes. The research team brings together national experts on workplace violence prevention practice and research, and collaboration with a major US company.
The Specific Aims of this project are to:
Specific Aim 1: Determine if tabletop exercises can be effective tools to train employees in applying written policies and procedures as measured through gains in knowledge and ability to implement policies and procedures.
Specific Aim 2: Determine if tabletop exercises can be effective tools to measure how written policies and procedures are implemented.
Specific Aim 3: Determine if tabletop exercises can be used to identify gaps in and barriers to the implementation of written policies and procedures.
- Page last reviewed: July 22, 2015
- Page last updated: July 6, 2015
- Content source:
- National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Office of the Director