Volume 2: No. 2, April 2005
ORIGINAL RESEARCH: FEATURED
ABSTRACT FROM THE 19TH NATIONAL CONFERENCE ON CHRONIC DISEASE
PREVENTION AND CONTROL
Trying to Quit: Low-Income Smokers’ Access to Cessation Care in a Managed Care Environment
Millicent Fleming-Moran, Kaigang Li, Joseph Gibson, Miriam Garland
Suggested citation for this article: Fleming-Moran M, Li K, Gibson J, Garland M. Trying to quit: low-income smokers’ access to cessation care in a managed care environment [abstract].
Prev Chronic Dis [serial online] 2005 Apr [date cited]. Available from: URL: http://www.cdc.gov/pcd/issues/2005/
Track: Methods and Surveillance
This study describes 295 smokers in a managed care safety-net insurance
program, where 63% received cessation advice during at least one visit in the
previous year. Our study asks: Does longer program enrollment increase a
smoker's likelihood of receiving cessation advice?
The study population is drawn from Advantage program clients who are
predominantly minority, working poor with Medicaid/Medicare or are under-insured
county residents who meet 200% or less of federal poverty guidelines. State
medical school practitioners coordinate the program in seven primary care
clinics in a Midwestern urban county.
Telephone surveys using Bellview CATI survey software (Pulse Train Software,
Ltd, Surrey, UK) were administered in English or Spanish to 731 Advantage
enrollees. Of these, 317 were enrolled for less
than one year, 281 were enrolled for one year, and 133 were enrolled for
more than one year. Of the 731 enrollees, 295 (40.4%) were current
smokers. The current smokers were categorized by
sex, ethnicity, age, education, knowledge of primary care physician (PCP),
and coronary heart disease (CHD) risk other than smoking. The association of
each characteristic with cessation advice was determined by chi-square tests of
significance. Predisposing factors (sex, age, ethnicity), enabling factors (education, known PCP), health
care need (other CHD risk), and program enrollment time
were tested in a logistic model of cessation advisement, using a forward selection process.
Advantage smokers who are female (72.0%), white (70.4%), and over age 65
(85.0%) and who know their PCP (68.5%) and have
another CHD risk factor (89.3%) report more advice than
smokers who are male (49.0%), minority (54.5%), and under age 35 (35.0%) and who do not know
their PCP (51.0%) or have any other CHD risk factors
(46.2%). Individuals who were enrolled for more than one year (71.2%) report more advice
than individuals enrolled for less than one year (53.1%). In logistic analysis, other CHD risk doubled the likelihood of cessation advice (odds ratio [OR] 2.02;
95% confidence interval [CI], 1.5–2.8),
as did being female (OR 1.95; CI, 1.1–3.3). Being over age 65 increased
the likelihood of advisement (OR 1.5; CI, 1.09–2.12), while minority status reduced
the likelihood (OR 0.41; CI, 0.24–.70). Enabling factors of education,
enrollment time, or PCP recognition did not enter the model.
Safety-net programs increase access to and continuity of primary care in
low-income communities where smoking is most prevalent. Advantage's 63%
advisement rate exceeds that reported for other smokers using primary care and
indicates appropriate outreach to high CHD risk smokers. More than one third (37%)
of smokers in Advantage's program,
however, report no cessation counseling. We propose examination of visit
patterns, language difficulties, and clinical smoking records as ways to track
and target younger, male, and minority smokers for provider prompts and
cessation support. Increasing access to cessation care would reduce CHD,
respiratory, and adverse reproductive outcomes in this population.
Corresponding Author: Millicent Fleming-Moran, PhD, Associate Professor, Indiana University, Department of Applied Health Science, HPER 116, Bloomington, IN 47401. Telephone: 812-855-8361. E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Back to top