|
|
Volume 5: No.
2, April 2008
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Addressing Stroke Signs and Symptoms
Through Public Education: The Stroke Heroes Act FAST Campaign
Hilary K. Wall, MPH, Brianne M. Beagan, MPH, H. June O’Neill, MPH, Kathleen M. Foell, RD, MS, Cynthia L. Boddie-Willis, MD, MPH
Suggested citation for this article: Wall HK, Beagan BM, O’Neill HJ, Foell KM, Boddie-Willis CL.
Addressing stroke signs and symptoms through public education: the Stroke Heroes Act FAST campaign. Prev Chronic Dis
2008;5(2).
http://www.cdc.gov/pcd/issues/2008/
apr/07_0214.htm. Accessed [date].
PEER REVIEWED
Abstract
Introduction
In 2003, only 18% of Massachusetts adults were aware of all signs and symptoms of stroke, but 80% would call 9-1-1 if they thought someone was having a stroke or heart attack. Because early recognition leads to early treatment and improved clinical outcomes, increasing symptom recognition could have an impact on stroke survival and
stroke patients’ quality of life.
Methods
We conducted secondary research to identify messages with evidence-based effectiveness for communicating stroke signs and symptoms. From these results,
a Stroke Heroes Act FAST animation was created and concept-tested. Non-Hispanic white and non-Hispanic black women aged 40
to 64 years received education on stroke signs and symptoms. Knowledge change
about stroke signs and symptoms was calculated immediately following and 3 months
after the education session.
Results
Using Stroke Heroes Act FAST educational materials that were developed, 72 women (mean age, 54 years; 15.5% were non-Hispanic blacks) received education about signs and symptoms of stroke and took the pretests and posttests to assess knowledge change. Immediately
after the education session, significant increases were seen in the percentage of participants who recognized that facial droop (92% vs 99%, P = .02) and arm weakness or numbness (86% vs 97%, P = .004) were symptoms of stroke. Of the 65 participants who were given the
3-month follow-up survey, 100% remembered slurred speech and facial drooping as
symptoms; 98.5% recalled arm weakness or numbness; and 97% would call 9-1-1 if they thought someone was having a stroke. None of these
is a significant change from the posttest.
Conclusion
The Stroke Heroes Act FAST kit may be a useful tool for improving knowledge of stroke signs and symptoms among adults.
Back to top
Introduction
Stroke is the third leading cause of death in the United States (1), and it is the third leading cause
of death in Massachusetts (2).
A national
Healthy People 2010 (HP 2010) goal is to reduce stroke deaths to 48 per 100,000 people (3). In 2004, 43 per 100,000 Massachusetts residents died from stroke,
whereas 50 per 100,000 people nationwide died from stroke (1). Moreover, in
2005, 3% of Massachusetts adults reported having had a stroke (4). Although the state’s stroke
death rate meets the
HP 2010 target, unpublished state vital records data indicate that deaths from stroke in
Massachusetts have not significantly decreased since 1994. Several communities
have disproportionately high rates of stroke risk factors, prevalence, and
death.
In June 1998, the Brain Attack Coalition, a group of national professional, volunteer,
and government entities dedicated to reducing stroke-related death and
disability, reached consensus on the symptoms of stroke. Previously,
standardized definitions for stroke signs and symptoms did not exist. The consensus symptoms
are sudden numbness or weakness of face, arm, or leg, especially on one side of the body; sudden confusion or trouble speaking or understanding speech; sudden
trouble seeing in one or both eyes; sudden trouble walking, dizziness, or loss of balance or coordination; and sudden severe headache with no known cause (5). These
“suddens” are commonly used to convey stroke symptoms in clinical and public health settings and among advocacy organizations concerned with stroke.
The “suddens” were adopted by several national and state-based educational campaigns. Since consensus was reached,
Massachusetts advocacy organizations have annually conducted at least one campaign on the
signs and symptoms of stroke. Yet in 2003, only 18% of Massachusetts adults were aware of all signs and symptoms of stroke (6), but 80% would call 9-1-1 if they thought someone was having a stroke or heart attack (6). Because early
recognition leads to early treatment and improved clinical outcomes, increasing symptom recognition could vastly improve stroke survival and quality of life (7).
In March 2004, the Massachusetts Public Health Council approved a primary stroke service (PSS) hospital designation (8). This state-level designation is conferred by the
Massachusetts Department of Public Health (MDPH), Division of Health Care Quality. Each hospital with this designation meets mandated criteria
based on guidelines for diagnosing and treating acute stroke patients. To address the lack of recognition of stroke symptoms in Massachusetts, the MDPH
Heart Disease and Stroke Prevention and Control Program (HSPC) successfully advocated for the inclusion of community education on stroke signs and symptoms in the PSS regulations.
Prior short-term studies have demonstrated that public education campaigns can increase stroke recognition (9-12) and the quickness with which stroke patients seek and receive appropriate care (9,13).
To support Massachusetts hospitals in meeting the PSS community education
requirements, HSPC began in July 2004 to explore effective stroke symptom messages
that were evidence-based and could be incorporated into
a long-term, comprehensive public education campaign. We present here the results of this effort.
Back to top
Methods
By combining state-appropriated funds for stroke education and federal funds from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, HSPC is implementing a comprehensive, evidence-based public education campaign. An analysis of stroke prevalence, mortality, and hospitalization surveillance data by race/ethnicity, age, and sex indicated that the initial priority population for the comprehensive campaign was English-speaking women who were either
non-Hispanic white or non-Hispanic black and the potential caregivers of these women. To guide stroke education in Massachusetts, a Stroke Signs and Symptoms Advisory Group was formed
comprising health professionals, stroke survivors, and representatives from communities
in which the risk for stroke, heart disease, or chronic disease is high.
Secondary research
A social marketing and communications company, Geovision, Inc, was hired to conduct secondary research on existing messages about stroke signs and symptoms.
It conducted a comprehensive literature search and informal inventory of other
unpublished sources. The results were used to develop an evidence-based approach to educating the lay public to recognize the signs of
stroke and respond by calling 9-1-1. The search for messages and materials
included online investigation and direct inquiry to national and international
medical, public health, academic, and advocacy agencies and organizations that
promote awareness, prevention, and treatment of stroke. These organizations
included state and international health departments, hospitals and research
centers, medical foundations, and universities. The search also included an
assessment of barriers to calling 9-1-1 in response to acute medical events
among the priority populations living in communities where the risk for stroke
is elevated. Existing knowledge and strategies relating to the effective placement of health communication materials about medical emergencies
were also assessed in the literature search.
Concept testing
Using results from the secondary research, Geovision created a 3-minute animation to teach the signs of stroke. We
convened five groups to test the concept of the animation: three
mixed-audience groups, one group of stroke educators, and one group of stroke survivors. All participants received financial compensation for attending a 90-minute session. We created three separate discussion guides to solicit comments on the animation concept and information content. Immediately
after viewing the animation and before any discussion, the mixed groups completed a brief survey to evaluate information recall and message resonance.
The three mixed-audience groups consisted of 1) non-Hispanic white and non-Hispanic black men and women aged 63 or older who had not had a stroke; 2) non-Hispanic white and non-Hispanic black adult children
of parents aged 65 or older; and 3) providers of community elder programs or
non-health–care services. Because of high prevalence of stroke and stroke-related hospitalization and mortality in Fall River, Lowell, and Springfield, residents in these communities were
recruited for the mixed-audience groups by professional telephone recruiters and community-based organizations. Participants provided information including age, household income levels, and employment status.
Twelve known stroke educators were contacted to participate in the stroke
educators concept testing group. Additionally, education staff from over 40
hospitals and health care organizations were solicited to participate in the
stroke educators group. Stroke survivors were recruited from a pool provided by MDPH, the Mt. Auburn Hospital Stroke Service Program, and the Watertown Senior Center.
Retention pilot
Risk of stroke is higher for older and low-income women, and the rate of
death from stroke more than triples with each added decade of life after the age of 45 (1). To assess message retention
from our public education model, we conducted a pilot project with several
cardiovascular disease risk reduction educators from the Well-Integrated Screening and Evaluation for Women Across the Nation (WISEWOMAN) program
from the MDPH Women’s Health Network. The network provides free breast and
cervical cancer screening and diagnostic services to low-income women aged 40 to
64. Sites selected to participate in WISEWOMAN provide heart disease and stroke
prevention services that include cardiovascular health risk assessment and
lifestyle interventions by the cardiovascular risk reduction educators. The project proposal was submitted to and approved by the MDPH Human Research Review Committee. HSPC trained the
educators, who in turn
taught stroke signs and symptoms to a group of Women’s Health Network clients.
Participants were asked to sign an informed consent form and provide basic demographic information. To assess changes in knowledge of stroke signs and symptoms,
participants were given a pretest and posttest immediately before and after the education session. Participants received a $10 grocery store gift card for attending the session. Three months later, a follow-up telephone survey
was conducted, after which participants received a $15 grocery store gift card.
Data were entered into Excel 2003 (Microsoft Corporation, Redmond,
Washington) and then exported to SAS (SAS Institute, Inc, Cary, North Carolina) for analysis. Descriptive statistics were determined for demographic variables. Paired t-tests were used to determine differences in mean between pretest and posttest results as well as posttest and 3-month follow-up results.
We considered the results of the paired t-tests statistically
significant when the corresponding P value was ≤.05.
Back to top
Results
Secondary research
Geovision identified 24 private organizations and 20 national health
departments and contacted them for sample materials. Three departments provided relevant program information and materials. Thirty articles were reviewed and summarized.
The search revealed that a comprehensive public awareness campaign that includes mass media can increase stroke recognition but should target family, coworkers, and caregivers of those at highest risk for stroke. Moreover, educational efforts should focus on behaviors that promote early seeking of hospital care.
The research, however, yielded a paucity of stroke education messages with evidence-based effectiveness. Among them was the Cincinnati Prehospital Stroke Scale (CPSS) (14), a three-item scale based on a simplification of the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (15),
which has high sensitivity and specificity for identifying stroke patients who are candidates for thrombolytic treatment when performed by a physician (15) and has similar results when used by prehospital care providers (14).
Moreover, the CPSS has been accurately administered by untrained laypeople to identify stroke signs in mock patients (16)
and in stroke survivors (17) when prompted by a 9-1-1 telecommunicator. On further investigation, we learned that the CPSS had been successfully modified
by adding a fourth item, so that it could be used by laypeople before they called 9-1-1. This item provided instructions for laypeople to call 9-1-1 if they observed stroke signs in someone. Kleindorfer et al created
the FAST acronym for lay assessment of stroke symptoms (Table 1) (18). During a retrospective chart review of 3500 stroke patients, the
authors found that the FAST message identified 88.9% of patients with stroke or transient ischemic attack (TIA) (i.e., brief stroke-like symptoms that can occur with no lasting damage) (18).
On the basis of its findings from the secondary research and on knowledge of basic memory techniques (e.g., mnemonics or acronyms, repetition, rhythm or songs), Geovision
recommended creating a 3-minute musical animation using the FAST acronym. The animation was concept-tested and produced for English speakers.
Concept testing
Of 41 people recruited for the three mixed-audience groups, 34 participated. The mean age of participants
was 58.1 years
(Table 2), and they included seniors (41%), adults with senior parents (38%), and health care workers who care for seniors (21%). Twenty-two participants (65%) were female, and
23 (68%) were non-Hispanic whites. Forty-four percent of participants earned less than $20,000 per
year.
Immediately after being shown the 3-minute animation, participants completed a brief form to assess information recall. From the three groups, 100% of participants indicated that the topic of the video was stroke
and identified the action to take at the first sign of a stroke
(call 9-1-1); 76.5% recalled the three symptom components of FAST (Face, Arm, and Speech).
Of the seven stroke survivors who participated in concept testing, three (43%) were female and all were non-Hispanic white
(Table 3). The mean age was 54.1 years. Four (57%) had had ischemic strokes (i.e., strokes caused by a blocked blood vessel in the brain).
Nine stroke educators were part of the final concept-testing group. All nine
were non-Hispanic white women, and they represented seven different hospitals or health care organizations. Their titles
were diverse and included neuroscience educator and director of rehabilitation services.
Participants from all five groups thought the animation provided a comfortable, upbeat,
“less scary” approach to a serious health issue, and that the animation and music
were simple, direct, and uncluttered. Participants consistently described the accompanying song as
“catchy” and the animation style as simple but appealing. Recommendations included creating
a visual reinforcement of the FAST checklist, depicting a
younger character in at least one of the scenarios, and accentuating the distorted speech bubble. Some stroke educators expressed concern about showing only the three most common symptoms without suggesting that other symptoms may indicate stroke.
Figure. Stroke Heroes Act FAST poster
We incorporated suggestions from the concept testing into a final animation and created a brochure and poster (Figure) using the characters from the animation. These pieces were included in a
Stroke Heroes Act FAST educational kit, which had instructive PowerPoint
presentations with information about stroke signs, symptoms, and risk
factors; an educator’s guide with strategies for effectively reaching lay
audiences; a press release; and evaluation forms. The kit, which we designed as a
train-the-trainer module, is available through HSPC.
Retention pilot
Seventy-two women participated in the retention pilot. One participant refused to provide demographic information. The mean age of participants was 53.7. Participants were primarily non-Hispanic whites (76%) and had never had a stroke (99%). Almost half (49%) of participants had a family history of stroke
(Table 4).
Immediately after the education session, we saw significant increases in the percentage of participants who recognized that facial droop (91.7% vs 98.6%, P = .02) and arm weakness or numbness (86.1% vs 97.2%, P = .004) were symptoms of stroke. Moreover,
we also saw significant increases in the percentage of participants who thought chest pain and shortness of breath were not stroke symptoms.
The percentage of participants who recognized
“call 9-1-1” as the action to take after observing stroke symptoms also increased significantly, from 81.9% to 98.6% (P < .001)
(Table 5).
Three months after the education session, we conducted a follow-up survey of the participants. Seven participants could not be reached. Of the 65 participants who were given the survey, 100% remembered slurred speech and facial drooping
as symptoms of stroke; 98.5% remembered arm weakness or numbness; 96.9% would call 9-1-1 if they thought someone was having a stroke. None of these
is a significant change from the posttest (Table 6). However, significantly fewer participants remembered correctly that chest pain
(87.7% vs 55.4%, P < .001) and shortness of breath (84.6% vs 50.8%, P < .001) were not symptoms of stroke. Moreover, the percentage of participants who recognized all components of the FAST acronym
declined significantly, from 100.0% to 78.5% (P < .001).
Back to top
Discussion
Concept testing of the Stroke Heroes Act FAST animation yielded positive results
for message recall and aesthetics. Despite concerns from stroke educators during concept testing that FAST does not convey all the signs and symptoms of stroke, Kleindorfer et al demonstrate that the FAST acronym successfully identified 88.9% of stroke patients (18).
In this assessment, we found that among women aged 45 to 64, using the FAST message through the
Stroke Heroes Act FAST kit is an effective way to facilitate short-term knowledge change and message retention about stroke signs and symptoms.
Although the scientific literature lacks messages that successfully affect knowledge of stroke signs and symptoms, the FAST acronym shows promise as an effective
memory device and message, especially when coupled with the colorful animation and
catchy tune in the Stroke Heroes Act FAST animation and accompanying materials. As Kleindorfer
et al conclude, however, whether the FAST message is
easier to recall than the “suddens” has yet to be determined (18).
Relevant changes from pretest to posttest include the significant increases in participants who recognized that facial droop and arm weakness or numbness
are symptoms of stroke, who would call 9-1-1 if they thought someone was having a stroke, and
who learned that the presence of only one symptom is enough to suspect someone is having a stroke. The ability of the
Stroke Heroes Act FAST kit to increase awareness of the latter two concepts could
increase the acceptance of stroke as an
emergency condition and lead to more prompt treatment and decreased death and disability
from stroke.
Stern et al observed a significant gain in stroke knowledge only immediately after an educational program was administered (11). Unlike Stern et al, however, we were able to conduct a follow-up assessment,
and we found no significant differences from the posttest to 3-month follow-up in the percentage of participants who recognized slurred speech, drooping of the face, and arm weakness or numbness as signs of stroke. However, almost half of participants had difficulty recalling that chest
pain and shortness of breath were not stroke signs. These results suggest that participants were confident in knowing the true signs of stroke but less so in ruling out false positives. However, because chest pain and shortness of breath are major signs of heart attack and almost all participants would call 9-1-1 if they thought someone was having a stroke independent of symptom presentation, a person suffering from these symptoms would still receive quick emergency response and care even if
their condition was incorrectly identified as stroke.
We noted some decrease in message retention after 3 months. The percentage of participants who recognized all components of the FAST acronym significantly declined from 100.0% to 78.5%. Although this retention rate
is high, it suggests that education on stroke signs and symptoms should be conducted periodically or perhaps enhanced with a media campaign. Consequently, the
Stroke Heroes Act FAST animation became the basis for an English-language mass media campaign, including television public
service announcements, transit card placards for subway and buses, and newspaper advertisements.
This campaign is being evaluated. The FAST message also will be culturally and linguistically adapted for Spanish, Portuguese, and Asian
audiences to educate the largest populations of non-English speakers in Massachusetts.
The main limitation of our analysis is the lack of power and sample size calculation. As a result, observed results may be due to chance. Future formal studies should be conducted with larger samples. Another limitation is that, because this was intended as a pilot project, we used a convenience sample
and, as a result, had more than two times the percentage of black, non-Hispanic women than
is found in the overall Massachusetts
population. Lastly, in our review of pertinent literature on stroke signs and symptoms education,
we found that investigators rarely specify the exact wording of the messaging used to
change knowledge. We hope that in the future, investigators will provide more detail about their education campaigns so that we can collectively evaluate
the success of these messages and develop better ones.
In our analysis, we have yet to assess whether the change in knowledge and message retention has resulted in improved time from stroke symptom onset to treatment.
Attributing any changes in
stroke patients’ arrival time at hospitals solely to the
Stroke Heroes Act FAST campaign and not to secular changes may be challenging.
Although national leaders in the treatment of stroke promote the use of the “suddens” for stroke signs and symptoms, to our knowledge this
device was developed by consensus and not tested for retention or ability to change knowledge. The findings show that the
Stroke Heroes Act FAST animation, which uses the FAST acronym and message, might be a useful tool for improving
knowledge of stroke signs and symptoms among adults.
Back to top
Acknowledgments
Funding from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is through
cooperative agreement #U50/CCU121351.
Stroke Heroes Act FAST kits are available through the Heart Disease and Stroke Prevention and Control Program at the Massachusetts Department of Public Health. Additional information is available by telephone, 866-627-7968, or e-mail, heart.stroke@state.ma.us. All supporting materials created as a result of this effort, including the brochure, poster, and
3-minute animation, are available free to requestors from Massachusetts, and for a nominal shipping fee for out-of-state requests,
at www.maclearinghouse.com.*
Back to top
Author Information
Corresponding Author: Hilary K. Wall, MPH, Massachusetts Department of Public Health, 250 Washington St, 4th Floor, Boston, MA 02108. Telephone: 617-624-5411. Fax: 617-624-5075. E-mail: hilary.wall@state.ma.us.
Author Affiliations: Brianne M. Beagan, H. June O’Neill, Kathleen M. Foell, Cynthia L. Boddie-Willis, Massachusetts Department of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts.
Back to top
References
- Miniño AM, Heron MP, Murphy SL, Kochanek KD.
Deaths: final data for 2004. Natl Vital Stat Rep 2007;55(19):1-119.
- Massachusetts deaths 2005. Boston (MA): Center for Health Information,
Statistics, Research, and Evaluation, Massachusetts Department of Public
Health; 2007. http://www.mass.gov/Eeohhs2/docs/dph/ research_epi/death_report_05.pdf.*
- Healthy People 2010: understanding and improving health and objectives for improving health. Vol. 1.
2nd ed. Washington (DC): U.S. Department of Health and Human Services; 2000.
- A profile of health among Massachusetts adults, 2005: results from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System. Boston (MA): Health Survey Program, Center for Health Information, Statistics, Research, and Evaluation, Massachusetts Department of Public Health; 2006.
- Coalition initiatives: stroke symptoms guide. Bethesda (MD): The Brain
Attack Coalition. http://www.stroke-site.org/coalition/stroke_symptoms.html.* Accessed October 1, 2007.
- Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System survey data. Boston (MA): Center for Health Information, Statistics, Research, and Evaluation, Massachusetts Department of Public Health; 2003.
- 2002 heart and stroke statistical update. Dallas (TX): American Heart Association; 2001.
- Advisory bulletin: primary stroke services. Circular letter: DHCQ
04-4-440. Boston (MA): Division of Health Care Quality, Department of Public Health, Executive Office of Health and Human Services, Massachusetts Department of Public Health; 2004. http://www.mass.gov/Eeohhs2/docs/dph/quality/ hcq_circular_letters/hospital_stroke_0404440.pdf.*
- Alberts MJ, Perry A, Dawson DV, Bertels C.
Effects of public and professional education on reducing the delay in presentation and referral of stroke patients. Stroke 1992;23(3):352-6.
- Dornan WA, Stroink AR, Pegg EE, Kattner KA, Gupta KL, Hayden CJ, et al. Community stroke awareness program increases public knowledge of stroke. Stroke 1998;29(1):288.
- Stern EB, Berman M, Thomas JJ, Klassen AC.
Community education for stroke awareness: an efficacy study. Stroke 1999;30(4):720-3.
- Becker K, Fruin M, Gooding T, Tirschwell D, Love P, Mankowski T.
Community-based education improves stroke knowledge. Cerebrovasc Dis 2001;11(1):34-43.
- Barsan WG, Brott TG, Broderick JP, Haley EC Jr, Levy DE, Marler JR.
Urgent therapy for acute stroke. Effects of a stroke trial on untreated patients. Stroke 1994;25(11):2132-7.
- Kothari RU, Pancioli A, Liu T, Brott T, Broderick J.
Cincinnati Prehospital Stroke Scale: reproducibility and validity. Ann Emerg Med 1999;33(4):373-8.
- Kothari R, Hall K, Brott T, Broderick J.
Early stroke recognition: developing an out-of-hospital NIH Stroke Scale. Acad Emerg Med 1997;4(10):986-90.
- Liferidge AT, Brice JH, Overby BA, Evenson KR.
Ability of laypersons to use the Cincinnati Prehospital Stroke Scale. Prehosp Emerg Care 2004;8(4):384-7.
- Hurwitz AS, Brice JH, Overby BA, Evenson KR.
Directed use of the Cincinnati Prehospital Stroke Scale by laypersons. Prehosp Emerg Care 2005;9(3):292-6.
- Kleindorfer DO, Miller R, Moomaw CJ, Alwell K, Broderick JP, Khoury J, et al.
Designing a message for public education regarding stroke: does FAST capture enough stroke? Stroke 2007;38(10):2864-8.
Back to top
|
|
