Changing Patterns of Pneumoconiosis Mortality --- United States, 1968--2000
Pneumoconioses are caused by the inhalation and deposition of mineral dusts in the lungs, resulting in pulmonary fibrosis and other parenchymal changes. Many persons with early pneumoconiosis are asymptomatic, but advanced disease often is accompanied by disability and premature death. Known pneumoconioses include coal workers' pneumoconiosis (CWP), silicosis, asbestosis, mixed dust pneumoconiosis, graphitosis, and talcosis. No effective treatment for these diseases is available (1). This report describes the temporal patterns of pneumoconiosis mortality during 1968--2000, which indicates an overall decrease in pneumoconiosis mortality. However, asbestosis increased steadily and is now the most frequently recorded pneumoconiosis on death certificates. Increased awareness of this trend is needed among health-care providers, employers, workers, and public health agencies.
The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) maintains a mortality surveillance system for respiratory diseases of occupational interest (2). The data are drawn from annual National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) multiple-cause-of-death mortality files, which include all deaths in the United States since 1968. For this report, pneumoconiosis deaths were identified during 1968--2000, the most recent year for which complete data are available, and include any death certificates for which an International Classification of Diseases (ICD) code* for CWP, silicosis, asbestosis, or unspecified/other pneumoconiosis was listed as either the underlying or contributing cause of death. Age-adjusted death rates (per million population per year) for periods of interest were calculated by using the mid-year population as a denominator. Age standardization was performed by using the 2000 U.S. Census population.
During 1968--2000, pneumoconiosis was recorded on 124,846 death certificates. Comparing 1968--1981 with 1982--2000, death rates among males declined 36% for CWP and approximately 70% for both silicosis and unspecified/other pneumoconiosis, but increased nearly 400% for asbestosis. For both sexes, the decline was smaller among non-Hispanic blacks (26%) than among non-Hispanic whites (40%) for CWP but similar or greater for silicosis and unspecified/other pneumoconiosis, whereas the death rates for asbestosis increased 448% among blacks versus 342% among whites. Death rates among females were substantially lower than among males and, except for asbestosis, indicated decreases among both non-Hispanic whites and blacks. Asbestosis death rates increased among those aged >45 years; otherwise, death rates for the various pneumoconioses decreased regardless of age category.
The number of asbestosis deaths increased from 77 deaths (annual age-adjusted death rate: 0.54 per million population) in 1968 to 1,493 deaths (6.88 per million) in 2000; deaths for all other pneumoconioses decreased (Figure 1). CWP was the most frequently recorded pneumoconiosis from 1968 until 1998, when it was surpassed by asbestosis. Silicosis mortality declined steadily and, since 1993, was the least recorded category of pneumoconiosis. The geographic distributions of mortality for each type of pneumoconiosis for the 1968--1981 and 1982--2000 periods indicate that asbestosis increased substantially throughout the United States, particularly in the coastal states, where asbestos was used frequently in shipbuilding (Figure 2); CWP and the other pneumoconioses, which tend to occur in the mining and industrial regions of the country, had either little change or a decline during the two study periods.
Information from death certificates regarding usual occupation and industry was available for deaths in selected states only for 1985--1999 (2) (Tables 1 and 2). During this period, ship and boat building/repairing was replaced by nonmetallic mineral/stone products as the industry with the highest proportionate mortality ratio (PMR) for asbestosis. In addition, explosives worker replaced mining machine operators as those whose occupation had the highest PMR for other/unspecified pneumoconiosis.
Reported by: MD Attfield, PhD, JM Wood, MS, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health; VC Antao, MD, GA Pinheiro, MD, EIS officers, CDC.
The decline in overall pneumoconiosis mortality is attributed to reductions in CWP, silicosis, and other/unspecified pneumoconiosis mortality. The overall decline in CWP mortality follows the general reduction in the coal mining workforce since the 1920s. The Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969 introduced lower dust limits in the mining environment to protect the health of the nation's coal miners (3). Resulting lower dust levels have contributed to major reductions in disease among actively employed coal miners (4); however, the full impact of dust control on CWP mortality is not yet known. As with coal mining, the number of workers exposed to hazardous silica dust has declined through the loss of jobs in heavy industry. In addition, dust limits for silica in the United States also have been reduced steadily for approximately 30 years (5). Both job losses and reductions in exposures have contributed to the decline in silicosis mortality.
Asbestosis is the only major pneumoconiosis to demonstrate increased mortality. Because asbestosis mortality peaks 40--45 years after initial occupational exposure to asbestos (6), this upward trend reflects past exposure to asbestos fibers. Asbestos consumption increased substantially during and after World War II, with a peak in 1975 followed by a steep decrease beginning in the 1980s (7). Given the temporal pattern of usage and latency and survival considerations, asbestosis-related mortality is expected to increase for at least another decade. Asbestos-containing materials that continue to be used in some workplaces and remain in buildings represent a potential risk.
The findings in this report are subject to at least five limitations. First, occupation and industry codes that meet NCHS quality criteria are available only for certain states and for certain years. Thus, PMRs only reflect the industrial and occupational profiles of those states in those years. Second, these codes represent only the usual industry and occupation as entered on each death certificate, which is not always the industry and occupation in which the decedent's causative exposure occurred. Third, the state of residence at death is not always the state in which the decedent's causative exposure occurred, especially given the typically long latency and chronic course of the pneumoconioses. Fourth, slight differences exist in the ICD coding for asbestosis between the 9th and 10th revisions. In the 10th revision, the rubric for code J61 is "pneumoconiosis due to asbestos and other mineral fibers," whereas the rubric for the 8th and 9th revisions was simply "asbestosis." The overall effect of this change is unclear but might have resulted in an increase in the number of cases between the 9th and 10th revisions (i.e., between 1998 and 1999). Because occupational fiber exposures were predominantly to asbestos, the net effect of this change probably is small; the trend of increasing asbestosis deaths (Figure 1) indicates no evidence of any substantial change during 1998--1999. Finally, as with any data based solely on death certificate information, cause of death information is subject to potential errors associated with disease diagnosis, recording, and coding. For example, this information can be impacted by temporal changes in public and medical awareness and practice. In the years after the Farmington, West Virginia, mine disaster in 1968, the nation's attention focused on hardships suffered by coal miners, with a possible attendant rise in recording of CWP on death certificates. More recently, focus on asbestosis has increased, with a marked increase in asbestos-related litigation (8). This trend also has raised awareness of asbestosis, likely leading to its more frequent diagnosis and recording on death certificates. In addition, new technologies such as computed tomography are used increasingly, resulting in increased diagnostic sensitivity for pneumoconiotic diseases.
Despite these limitations, the national mortality data offer substantial benefits: they are national in scope, well documented, and readily available. These data are used to provide historical perspective on pneumoconiosis mortality and, given sufficient time lag, can be used to assess the effectiveness of preventive measures. They also can provide useful information on pneumoconiosis by location, industry, and occupation, suggesting ways in which to target preventive intervention and disease-management resources.
Considerable progress has been made toward elimination of the pneumoconioses. Nevertheless, certain pneumoconioses considered to be nearly eliminated are still occurring and causing deaths, even among young workers in the United States (9,10). Pneumoconioses are preventable, and efforts to eliminate these diseases should continue.
This report is based on contributions by G Syamlal, MPH, C Philips, RM Castellan, MD, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, CDC.
* ICDA-8 (1968--1978), ICD-9 (1979--1998), and ICD-10 (1999--2000) (2).
Return to top.
Return to top.
Disclaimer All MMWR HTML versions of articles are electronic conversions from ASCII text into HTML. This conversion may have resulted in character translation or format errors in the HTML version. Users should not rely on this HTML document, but are referred to the electronic PDF version and/or the original MMWR paper copy for the official text, figures, and tables. An original paper copy of this issue can be obtained from the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office (GPO), Washington, DC 20402-9371; telephone: (202) 512-1800. Contact GPO for current prices.
**Questions or messages regarding errors in formatting should be addressed to email@example.com.
Page converted: 7/22/2004
This page last reviewed 7/22/2004