Skip directly to search Skip directly to A to Z list Skip directly to navigation Skip directly to page options Skip directly to site content


workers, building, architect

NORA Manufacturing Sector Strategic Goals

R039800 - 021H: Evaluation of Tritum: Relative Biological Effectiveness and Cancer Mortality (9800)

Start Date: 9/1/2010
End Date: 8/31/2012

Principal Investigator (PI)
Name: Joan Karr
Organization: NIOSH
Sub-Unit: Office of Extramural Projects
Funded By: NIOSH

Primary Goal Addressed

Secondary Goal Addressed


Attributed to Manufacturing


Project Description

Short Summary

They will utilize Bayesian methods to estimate the Relative Biological Effectiveness (RBE) of tritium with reference to gamma radiation. The RBE has been reevaluated by a number of radiation experts, and is the subject of a recent systematic review. They will utilize the information compiled over the years at Savannah River Site (SRS) to directly address the relationship between cancer mortality and tritium exposure. They will consider cancer mortality and tritium exposure in conjunction with other radiation dose measures recorded among SRS employees. This work will address a form of radiation that has received little attention, despite its relevance to human populations. In addition, this work will assist the NIOSH in decision-making concerning compensation for cancer outcomes among nuclear facility workers.


"X-rays and gamma radiation are well-established carcinogens with substantial evidence of carcinogenicity in humans from epidemiological research. In contrast, there is very little epidemiological research on the human health effects of beta radiation. Even less is understood about the effects of chronic exposure to beta-emitters, such as tritium, a low-energy radioisotope of hydrogen that is produced through nuclear fuel production. Radiation protection standards assign a relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of 1 for beta-emitters compared to gamma-emitters. However, a recent scientific review concluded that the RBE of tritium needs reevaluation. The goal of this proposed study is twofold. First, we propose to estimate the RBE of tritium based on data from the existing literature. The ultimate goal is to apply an accurate RBE for tritium to examine the relationship between chronic, low-dose tritium exposure and cancer among a cohort of nuclear production workers at the Savannah River Site (SRS), the nation�s only large-scale tritium production facility. Second, we propose to utilize the information regarding the RBE of tritium to reevaluate the cancer mortality associated with other forms of radiation exposure in conjunction with tritium at the SRS facility.

Worker information, including annual tritium and gamma radiation dose, is enumerated for 18,883 workers employed from 1951-1999. Using this data, we propose to establish the distribution of the RBE of tritium with gamma as our reference form of radiation. Recognizing that quantification of a dose-response function for the tritium component of SRS workers will be highly imprecise due to the low magnitudes of tritium doses, we will employ Markov Chain Monte Carlo estimation, a technique that will allow us to establish an a priori distribution based on data from laboratory studies and to test how well an epidemiologic dataset � the SRS cohort data -- fits that distribution. Finally, we will use these estimates to provide more accurate evaluation of the relationship between chronic, low-dose radiation exposure and cancer outcomes.


Mission Relevance

There is very little epidemiological evidence concerning the effects of protracted exposures to tritium and its relative biological effectiveness compared to gammaemitters. The USDOE Savannah River Site is unique in that it was involved in tritium production for nuclear weapons. The goal of this project is to evaluate the association between cancer and estimated tritium dose in this cohort. In addition, they will use Markov Chain Monte Carlo methods to combine current information on the RBE for tritium with our epidemiological data in order to estimate a (posterior) distribution of the RBE for tritium.