NIOSHTIC-2 Publications Search
Association of television viewing time with overweight/obesity independent of meeting physical activity guidelines: do joint exposures yield independence?
Stabler-ME; Giacobbi-PR Jr.; Fekedulegn-DB
J Epidemiol 2013 Sep; 23(5):396-397
Inoue and colleagues published results from a crosssectional mail survey that examined the joint associations of television viewing time and a categorical estimate of moderate to vigorous physical activity (MVPA) with overweight/obesity in older Japanese adults. While it is fitting to draw conclusions regarding the joint associations of television viewing time and MVPA with body composition, the authors inappropriately concluded that spending less time watching TV reduced the "risk" of being overweight or obese "independent" of meeting physical activity guidelines (MVPA). The purpose of this editorial is to question the use of this terminology in their conclusion from a statistical and epidemiological perspective. We propose that the effect of TV viewing time on obesity, independent of MVPA, could not be inferred from the statistical model they fit and we therefore suggest an alternative model specification that would test the independent effects. The authors created a new exposure variable that combined the levels of television viewing time (low, high) and MVPA (insufficient, sufficient) and classified the study participants into 4 categories. They fit logistic regression models relating overweight/obesity (>25 kg/m2) to the 4-level exposure variable, adjusting for potential confounders. Odds ratios comparing the odds of being overweight/obese were computed for each combination of TV viewing time and MVPA using high TV viewing time and insufficient MVPA as the referent group. However, it is generally inappropriate to conclude independent contributions of television viewing and MVPA to body composition, unless both exposure variables were being controlled for in the same model as separate variables. As demonstrated by Merikanto et al (2012), to properly examine the association of TV viewing time and obesity independent of MVPA, the appropriate statistical modeling approach includes fitting a model relating obesity to TV viewing time, MVPA, and the interaction between the 2 predictors. If the interaction term is significant, then a model that examines the effect of TV viewing time at each level of MVPA could be fit. In the absence of an interaction effect, a main-effects model that contains the 2 predictors in the same model would enable one to make appropriate inferences regarding independent effects of the factors. Further discussion on interaction between two exposures is presented by Mutsert et al (2009).3 The study by Merikanto et al (2012) demonstrates appropriate use of a statistical modeling strategy for testing the independent effects of 3 exposure variables (chronotype, sleep duration, and sufficient sleep) on cardiovascular disease-related morbidity and type 2 diabetes. In their analysis, Merikanto et al (2012) fit a multivariate logistic regression model that contained all 3 predictor variables simultaneously. In conclusion, the authors accomplished their study aim of testing the joint association of television viewing and MVPA with body composition. However, we believe they inaccurately used the term "independent" to interpret their results when they concluded that less TV viewing time is associated with reduced risk of obesity "independent" of meeting PA guidelines. Potential solutions are to utilize prevalent-sensitive measures (eg, avoid risk-like wording) and avoid conclusions that claim independence between variables transformed as joint-exposures.
Physical-fitness; Physical-exercise; Body-weight; Weight-factors; Demographic-characteristics; Sociological-factors; Epidemiology; Statistical-analysis; Models; Exposure-levels; Sleep-disorders; Cardiovascular-function
Meagan E. Stabler, Department of Epidemiology, School of Public Health, West Virginia University, P.O. Box 9190, Medical Center Drive, Morgantown WV 26506-9190
Issue of Publication
Journal of Epidemiology
Page last reviewed: April 12, 2019
Content source: National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health Education and Information Division