Visual Assessment Versus Calculation of BMI - Example 3: Lisa

Example 3

Photo of Lisa

Lisa is another 4 year-old girl. Does she appear to be classified as:

Your visual assessment: Lisa is underweight.

Let’s assess for overweight or obesity by calculating BMI.

Lisa’s height is 39.2 inches and her weight is 38.6 pounds.

BMI = weight / height / height x 703

Enter her BMI here:
That’s incorrect. Please try again.

 

Show/Hide BMI Calculator

BMI Calculator - English

1. Height:
feet
inch(es)

2. Weight:
pounds
(Note: 8 ounces = 0.5 pounds)

Results:  

 

 

Show me the answer

38.6 / 39.2 / 39.2 x 703 = 17.7

That’s right. Lisa’s BMI = 17.7

Now, plot her BMI on the appropriate chart for her age and interpret the findings.



That’s incorrect. Please try again.

On the girls BMI-for-age chart, find Lisa’s age on the horizontal axis, and visually draw a vertical line up from that point. Then, find her BMI on the vertical axis, and visually draw a horizontal line across from that point. The point where the two intersect represents Lisa’s BMI-for-age.

Her age = 4 years
Her BMI = 17.7

Growth chart showing Lisa's BMI plotted on graph.

Plotted on the BMI-for-age chart for girls, Lisa’s BMI-for-age falls on the 94th percentile so she would be classified as overweight.

Your visual assessment was that Lisa is normal weight.

 

The point of this exercise is to demonstrate the difficulty of making a consistently accurate visual assessment of healthy weight, overweight or obesity. To make a consistently accurate determination of overweight or obesity, BMI must be determined and plotted on the appropriate growth chart for the appropriate age.