Threefold Increases in Population HIV Viral Load Suppression Among Men and Young Adults — Bukoba Municipal Council, Tanzania, 2014–2017

Reducing HIV-related morbidity and mortality, and effectively eliminating HIV transmission risk, depends on use of antiretroviral therapy (ART) to achieve and maintain viral load suppression (VLS)* (1,2). By 2020, sub-Saharan African countries are working to achieve VLS among 90% of persons using ART and 73% of all persons living with HIV infection (1). In Tanzania, a country with 1.4 million persons with HIV infection, 49.6% of HIV-positive persons aged 15-49 years had achieved VLS in 2017, including only 21.5% of men and 44.6% of women aged 25-29 years (3). To identify interventions that might increase VLS in Tanzania, and reduce VLS-associated sex and age-group disparities, the Bukoba Combination Prevention Evaluation (BCPE) scaled up new HIV testing, linkage to care, and retention on ART interventions throughout Bukoba Municipal Council (Bukoba), Tanzania, during October 2014-March 2017 (4,5). Located on the western shore of Lake Victoria, Bukoba is a mixed urban and rural municipality of 150,000 persons and capital of Kagera Region. Of the 31 regions of Tanzania, Kagera has the fourth highest prevalence of HIV infection (6.8%) among residents aged 15-49 years (3). CDC analyzed data from BCPE preintervention and postintervention surveys and found that VLS prevalence among HIV-positive Bukoba residents aged 18-49 years increased approximately twofold overall (from 28.6% to 64.8%) and among women (33.3% to 67.8%) and approximately threefold among men (20.5% to 59.1%) and young adults aged 18-29 years (15.6% to 56.7%). During 2017, BCPE facility-based testing and linkage interventions were approved as new service delivery models by the Tanzania Ministry of Health, Community Development, Gender, Elderly and Children (4,5). After a successful rollout to 208 facilities in 11 regions in 2018, BCPE interventions are being scaled up in all regions of Tanzania in 2019 with support from the United States President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR).†.

Reducing HIV-related morbidity and mortality, and effectively eliminating HIV transmission risk, depends on use of antiretroviral therapy (ART) to achieve and maintain viral load suppression (VLS)* (1,2). By 2020, sub-Saharan African countries are working to achieve VLS among 90% of persons using ART and 73% of all persons living with HIV infection (1). In Tanzania, a country with 1.4 million persons with HIV infection, 49.6% of HIV-positive persons aged 15-49 years had achieved VLS in 2017, including only 21.5% of men and 44.6% of women aged 25-29 years (3). To identify interventions that might increase VLS in Tanzania, and reduce VLS-associated sex and age-group disparities, the Bukoba Combination Prevention Evaluation (BCPE) scaled up new HIV testing, linkage to care, and retention on ART interventions throughout Bukoba Municipal Council (Bukoba), Tanzania, during October 2014-March 2017 (4,5). Located on the western shore of Lake Victoria, Bukoba is a mixed urban and rural municipality of 150,000 persons and capital of Kagera Region. Of the 31 regions of Tanzania, Kagera has the fourth highest prevalence of HIV infection (6.8%) among residents aged 15-49 years (3). CDC analyzed data from BCPE preintervention and postintervention surveys and found that VLS prevalence among HIV-positive Bukoba residents aged 18-49 years increased approximately twofold overall (from 28.6% to 64.8%) and among women (33.3% to 67.8%) and approximately threefold among men (20.5% to 59.1%) and young adults aged 18-29 years (15.6% to 56.7%). During 2017, BCPE facility-based testing and linkage interventions were approved as new service delivery models by the Tanzania Ministry of Health, Community Development, Gender, Elderly and Children (4,5). After a successful rollout to 208  Household surveys conducted before (November 2013-January 2014) and after (June-September 2017) the interventions used identical methods to assess prior diagnosis of HIV infection, current ART use, and VLS among persons with HIV infection. In Bukoba census enumeration areas randomly selected in proportion to ward § § population, all household members aged 18-49 years were eligible for an in-person interview and HIV testing. Specimens obtained from HIV-positive participants were tested at the national laboratory for HIV-1 viral load. Preintervention and postintervention prevalence, VLS prevalence ratios (PRs), and adjusted prevalence ratios (aPRs) were estimated using SAS (version 9.3; SAS Institute). All estimates were census-weighted by sex, age group, and geographic area, and adjusted for clustering within enumeration areas. ¶ All patients seeking outpatient department medical services at three faith-based and all eight government health care facilities (excluding police and military) were routinely screened and offered HIV testing if eligible by national guidelines. HIV testing was offered at least once at all homes throughout Bukoba and at 79 venues frequented by men (e.g., businesses, bars, community events, and high-traffic urban areas Among residents aged 18-49 years in sampled enumeration areas, 4,795 (73%) of 6,532 residents participated in preintervention survey interviews and HIV testing, and 5,067 (74%) of 6,844 residents participated in postintervention survey interviews and HIV testing. For both surveys, proportionally fewer men than women were contacted, interviewed, and tested for HIV infection (Figure).

TABLE 1. Preintervention prevalence of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection among residents aged 18-49 years; preintervention prevalence of prior diagnosis of HIV infection, current enrollment in HIV care, and current use of antiretroviral therapy (ART) among HIV-positive residents aged 18-49 years; and intervention targets and outcomes -Bukoba Combination Prevention Evaluation, Bukoba
VLS prevalence among all persons with HIV infection increased approximately twofold overall (from 28.6% to 64.8%), among women (33.3% to 67.8%), and among those who had lived in their home for >2 years (34.4% to 70.4%). VLS prevalence increased approximately threefold among men (20.5% to 59.1%), persons aged 18-29 years (15.6% to 56.7%), and those who had unprotected sexual intercourse (17.7% to 54.9%) ( Table 2). VLS sex and age group disparities in 2014 (aPR = 1.5-2.7) were nearly eliminated by 2017 (aPR = 1.1-1.3). With the exception of cell phone or television ownership, VLS prevalence disparities were not observed in 2017 for other sociodemographic characteristics ( Table 2).

Discussion
After implementation of a new community-wide combination prevention intervention in Bukoba during a 2.5-year period of expanding ART eligibility, VLS prevalence among HIV-positive residents aged 18-49 years increased approximately twofold overall and approximately threefold among men and young adults aged 18-29 years, two groups known to have low VLS coverage in Tanzania and elsewhere (1,3). Although benefiting from only 6 months of Test and Start (ART for all HIV-positive persons), BCPE nearly achieved  the 73% VLS prevalence target for women, persons aged 40-49 years, and residents living in their current home >2 years. Findings from BCPE suggest that comprehensive medical outpatient department and community-based HIV testing strategies, combined with Test and Start and recommended linkage and defaulter-tracing services, can substantially increase VLS prevalence and reduce VLS-associated sex and age group disparities in a relatively short time.

TABLE 2. Preintervention and postintervention household survey participant characteristics, population prevalence of viral load suppression (VLS)* among persons with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection aged 18-49 years, and VLS prevalence ratios -Bukoba Combination Prevention Evaluation, Bukoba
Although not measured in BCPE, reduction in incidence of HIV infection in Bukoba since 2014 is possible based on the large increase in VLS prevalence, including a threefold increase in VLS among HIV-positive persons who had unprotected sexual intercourse (2). In a community-randomized trial in Botswana, annual incidence of HIV infection was reduced approximately 30% in intervention communities with a smaller net increase, but higher VLS prevalence, compared with BCPE (6).
A Test and Start trial conducted in 16 rural communities of approximately 5,000 residents each in Kenya and Uganda increased VLS prevalence among HIV-positive residents by an absolute difference of 35.5% (from 44.7% to 80.2%) (7). In a 2-year period, ART was provided to all persons with HIV infection through community health campaigns and homebased HIV testing services, an intervention strategy that might not be as effective in larger urban communities such as Bukoba (7). BCPE interventions met or exceeded overall targets for diagnosis of HIV infection and enrollment-in-care, helping to increase VLS prevalence by a similar absolute difference of 36.2% (from 28.6% to 64.8%). However, the 73% VLS prevalence target was not met, in part, because most (81%) BCPE HIV-positive clients were enrolled in care before Test and Start and many patients had defaulted from HIV care. Although comprehensive defaulter-tracing services included retracing defaulters, many patients were lost to follow-up (706 before Test and Start). Implemented under nonexperimental, realworld conditions, BCPE findings are consistent with reports of low retention in HIV care in sub-Saharan Africa before Test and Start (8). Thus, achieving ≥73% VLS prevalence among persons with HIV infection in Tanzania might not only depend on optimizing HIV testing and ART linkage services, but also on concerted efforts to improve retention and identify and return to ART care many patients who might have defaulted before Test and Start (8).
Notably, exceeding the preintervention target for testing HIV-positive persons in need of diagnosis (109%) should have resulted in a higher postintervention prevalence of prior diagnosis of HIV infection (76%). Beyond uncertainty of census and sample survey prevalence estimates, two reasons likely explain this difference. First, although intervention target counts of clients who received a new HIV diagnosis were restricted to those referred to Bukoba facilities, some of these clients might not have resided in Bukoba (which is home to the regional referral hospital and two health centers known to provide medical services to residents from other districts). Second, because comprehensive testing, linkage, and retention interventions were not scaled up in other districts, fewer

Summary
What is already known about this topic?
Achieving and sustaining viral load suppression (VLS) reduces illness and death associated with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection and effectively prevents sexual transmission of HIV.
What is added by this report?
In Bukoba, Tanzania, scale-up of new testing, linkage to care, and retention on antiretroviral therapy interventions over 2.5 years helped increase VLS among HIV-positive persons approximately twofold overall (from 28.6% to 64.8%) and threefold among men (20.5% to 59.1%) and adults aged 18-29 years (15.6% to 56.7%).
What are the implications for public health practice?
During 2019, these interventions are being scaled up across Tanzania with support from the U.S. President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief to help increase VLS among all persons with HIV infection.
persons who had previously received an HIV diagnosis might have moved into than out of Bukoba during the 2.5-year intervention (differential migration). Differential migration might have contributed to potentially lower VLS prevalence in 2017 among persons with HIV infection who reported living in their home for <1 year (57%) compared with >2 years (70%).
The findings in this report are subject to at least four limitations. First, because the evaluation did not include control communities, the effect of BCPE interventions on population VLS prevalence could not be estimated. Second, although prevalence estimates were weighted to the census population, residual bias might reduce the validity of estimates for men who were underrepresented in both surveys. Third, residence of clients who received BCPE testing and linkage services was not collected and is unknown. Finally, despite adjustment for VLS, estimated prevalence of prior diagnosis of HIV infection and ART use might be underestimated because of low sensitivity of self-report (9).
In 2017, BCPE facility-based HIV testing and linkage case management interventions were approved as new service delivery models by the Ministry of Health, and were implemented in 2018 by four nongovernmental organizations in 208 health care facilities and as part of community-based services in 11 regions of Tanzania (4,5). PEPFAR is supporting the nationwide scale-up of BCPE interventions in Tanzania in 2019 and recommends optimized provider-initiated HIV testing services and peer-delivered, linkage case management as potential strategies for countries to help achieve ≥73% prevalence of VLS among all persons with HIV infection by the end of 2020 (10).