|
|
|
An emissions assisted maintenance procedure (EAMP) was developed to help
mine operators implement the MSHA regulation that requires emissions testing
of diesel-powered mine equipment. The EAMP provides mine operators with a
sound method that meets all of the requirements of the new regulation. It also
provides a framework in which mine operators can develop a procedure that
includes measurement of additional emission. Detailed instructions for
implementing the EAMP will be provided in an a separate publication entitled,
"EAMP Training Manual."
All the significant factors that affect emissions were considered before a
procedure was developed to utilize emissions to identify a need for
maintenance. The effects on engine emissions of fuel, ambient conditions,
engine wear, engine design, engine speed, load, and engine faults were all
examined as part of the EAMP development. The EAMP accurately identifies
engines in need of maintenance by controlling the variables that could
otherwise lead to erroneous test results. Previously developed methods to
perform on-site emission tests were also reviewed to extract those components
most needed in an underground environment.
The EAMP proved to be effective in the laboratory and in the field. CO and CO2
measurements were used to identify clean, dirty, and clogged air filter
conditions at greater than 95% full load at two different speeds. By the c2red
test, no significant disagreement was detected between the portable analyzer
measurements and the laboratory-grade analyzer measurements. In the field, the
procedure indicated differences in emission concentrations between some of the
similar engine models. These differences indicated that there was a need for
further inspection and possible maintenance. Tests repeated on different days
indicated that the torque converter stall loading method could be repeated
such that the CO2 concentration varied less than 5%. Furthermore, the engine
loading and sampling methods were straightforward and easily performed by mine
maintenance personnel. Based upon the data collected, the development of the
EAMP training manual should not require additional field research.
There are still improvements that could be made to optimize the EAMP. The
portable analyzer and PC combination, used in the field, proved to be somewhat
bulky. A hand-held analyzer with the accuracy of the Ecom-AC and the data
graphing and recording capabilities of the laptop PC would be ideal and more
readily accepted by mine maintenance personnel.
No matter what instrument is ultimately chosen, a baseline emission database
should be established to implement the EAMP most equitably. It was shown that
engine models produce characteristic normal, or baseline emissions. A
database, consisting of baseline full-load CO and CO2
concentrations for
specific engine models, would ensure that all mine operators would expect
similar emissions from similar engines. Until this database is established, it
will be the mine operator's responsibility to use new or properly operating
engines to determine baseline emissions for each engine model. To make
maintenance decisions, mine operators will have to rely upon comparisons
between their weekly test results and their self-determined baseline
emissions. A basic guide on how to establish reasonable baseline emissions and
how to make judgments based on these baselines will be provided in the EAMP
training manual. No extended field research has been conducted to conclude
whether or not the EAMP is effective in identifying specific engine faults,
however. Currently the EAMP will only determine whether or not there is a need
for engine maintenance. Depending upon further research, a supplement to the
EAMP training manual may provide information about identifying specific engine
faults with the EAMP. This supplement also may provide an initial database of
baseline emissions. MSHA may generate this database during its equipment
approval process. Performing the EAMP on equipment before the equipment leaves
the manufacturer may also be a practical means of generating baseline emission
data.
The EAMP will still be useful without an emission database and without the
conclusions of the specific fault identifying research. The EAMP can identify
equipment that exceeds the MSHA CO limit of 2500 ppm, and it can detect trends
and changes in emissions that indicate a need for maintenance. The EAMP will
provide mine operators with a valuable tool that can help minimize worker
exposure to diesel emissions, and it can also help increase production by
identifying those engines that may otherwise break down unexpectedly. This
procedure will only become more valuable as supplemental information is
generated.
|