For years, mine operators, federal and state mine safety agencies, and researchers have looked at numerous aspects of mine emergency response. The 2006 multi-fatality incidents at the Sago, Alma, and Darby mines raised a number of issues about mine emergency preparedness and response, particularly as they relate to:
miners’ donning of and expectations when wearing an SCSR and the need to switch to additional units for escape;
miners’ judgment and decision-making processes under the stress and uncertainty of a mine escape;
the layout and marking of emergency escapeways in mines and miners’ familiarity with escape procedures;
wayfinding and navigation in smoke; and
the psycho-social consequences of mine emergency escape.
Research is being conducted to assess 1) the effectiveness of realistic smoke training for escaping miners, and 2) technologies such as hand held lasers, high intensity LED lighting or strobe lights, sonic sensing devices, chemical light sticks, and directional lifelines that can be used to aid miners during escape. Researchers developed a training protocol to teach escaping miners how to successfully switch to a second SCSR if needed to escape the mine. Results of this work were coupled with additional training materials on SCSR expectations. Additional research is planned in selected areas of mine escape training. This work will include research tasks addressing the following issues:
teaching mine trainers and safety practitioners how to conduct miner escape competency assessments by developing methods of evaluating competencies and assessment tools;
teaching mine trainers how to create emergency evacuation decision-making exercises by providing guidance to mine
trainers on how to develop engaging new mine evacuation training scenarios that are relevant to the conditions at their particular mine;
development and field testing of new materials for training miners to properly use wireless two-way mine communication systems during emergencies; and
development and field testing of materials for training miners to communicate nonverbally while wearing an SCSR.
Researchers have developed a DVD training module to educate both new, inexperienced miners as well as veterans on important issues related to self-rescue and escape procedures. The module is built around interviews with two miners who survived and escape the massive explosion that rocked the underground workings of the Farmington No. 9 Mine in West Virginia in 1968. The module consists of a 25-minute video and instructor’s guide for use in safety training or other settings. The target audience consists of all underground mine workers, regardless of commodity. This training video will help safety instructors better prepare both new, inexperienced miners as well as veterans for the situations they could encounter should they have to escape an underground mine following an explosion. This "expectations" training will help miners to better respond should an explosion occur. The training module will also provide a powerful reminder to all miners that it is critical to make safety an everyday practice.
Research has also been conducted to study select issues in the deployment and use of refuge alternatives in underground coal mine. Researchers completed a training exercise to aid miners in the judgment and decision-making process when deciding whether to seek refuge as well as an exercise for providing expectations training in using a refuge chamber.
NIOSH Projects and Activities
Project
Objective
SCSR Switchover Procedure and Expectations Training
Enhance miners' ability to switch from one self-contained self-rescuer to another; provide expectations training on what it is like to wear an SCSR
Best Practices for Mine Escape Training
Ensure that suitable information exists for properly training underground coal miners to escape from dangerous situations caused by fires, explosions, and inundations
Contracts and Grants
Title
Contractor
Objective
Dynamic Decision-Making in Mine Emergency Situations (200-2009-31403)
Carnegie Mellon University
Develop practical guidelines and tools for decision-making in mine emergencies
Guidelines for Instructional Materials on Refuge Chamber Setup, Use, and Maintenance Klein-KA; Hall-EE | Pittsburgh, PA: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2009-148, Information Circular 9514, 2009 July; :1-33
Barricading Makes a Comeback? Brnich-MJ Jr.; Vaught-C | Falls Church, VA: U.S. Department of Labor, Mine Safety and Health Administration, Holmes Safety Association Bulletin, 1997 Nov; :14
Behavioral and Organizational Dimensions of Underground Mine Fires Vaught-C; Brnich-MJ; Mallett-LG; Cole-HP; Wiehagen-WJ; Conti-RS; Kowalski-KM; Litton-CD | Pittsburgh, PA: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, NIOSH, DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2000-126, Information Circular 9450, 2000 May :1-240
The Emergency Communication Triangle Mallett-L; Vaught-C; Brnich-MJ | US Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 99-157, 1999 Oct; :1-16
Groups in Emergency Situations: Behavior and Interaction During Escapes from Mine Fires [Dissertation] Mallett-LG | Lexington, KY: University of Kentucky, Department of Sociology, 1998
Mine Rescue and Response Conti-RS | Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Coal Research - Coal the Future (Sep 12-15, 2000; Sandton, Republic of South Africa). Symposium Series S26, International Committee for Coal Research, Washington, DC; :127-136
Responders To Underground Mine Fires Conti-RS | Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Conference of the Institute on Mining Health, Safety and Research (Aug 5-7, 2001; Salt Lake City, UT), University of Utah; :111-121
Worker Responses To Realistic Evacuation Training Vaught-C; Mallett-LG; Kowalski-KM; Brnich-MJ Jr | Proceedings of the International Emergency Management Society (TIEMS) Conference 1997, Copenhagen, Denmark: 1997 Jan; :55-62
Products
Escape from Farmington No. 9 - An Oral History(Training exercise, DVD) Brnich-MJ Jr.; Vaught-C; Caruso-DL; Urban-CW | Pittsburgh, PA: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, NIOSH, Office on Mine Safety and Health Research, DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2009-142D, 2009 May
Harry's Hard Choices: Mine Refuge Chamber Training, Instructors Guide(Training exercise) Vaught-C; Hall-EE; Klein-KA | Pittsburgh, PA: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2009-122, IC 9511
Belt Fire Exercise(Training exercise) University of Kentucky; USBM | USBM research contract H0348040; 1989 Jul
Care and Maintenance of Self-Contained Self-Rescuers (http://www.msha.gov/interactivetraining.htm) (Training exercise) NIOSH, Mine Safety and Health Administration | Multiple training modules for various SCSR models, 2005
Continuous Miner Fire(Training exercise) Southwest Virginia Community College; University of Kentucky | USBM research contract H0348040; 1989 Jul