Mining Publication: Investigation of Temperature Rise in Mobile Refuge Alternatives
Original creation date: March 2014
One of the initial and persistent concerns over the use of mobile refuge alternatives (RA) is the temperature rise inside the RA from the metabolic heat of the occupants and the heat released by the CO2 scrubbing system. Moreover, the humidity within the RA will increase as the occupants lose water through respiration and perspiration. The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Office of Mine Safety and Health Research (OMSHR) in its 2007 report to Congress on refuge alternatives recommended that refuge alternatives be designed and deployed to ensure that a temperature-humidity metric known as apparent temperature not exceed 95°F. Subsequently the Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) adopted this recommendation [30 CFR 7.504 (b)(1)].
Notwithstanding the above process, a standard method to determine compliance with this metric does not exist. The heat transfer process in an RA, including the contributions of the human occupants, is highly complex, and is not easily defined analytically or experimentally. NIOSH initiated research in 2008 with the goal of developing a technical foundation for such analytical and experimental procedures. Based on a significant amount of preliminary work at the Lake Lynn Experimental Mine, at NIOSH’s Pittsburgh Research Laboratory, and at manufacturer facilities, the project was focused to address four research questions.
- Does the mine behave as an infinite heat sink? The engineering assumption that a mine does behave as an infinite heat sink was applied in the calculations originally used to certify mobile RAs, and is being applied in the design of tests to the present. If a mine can be assumed to behave as an infinite heat sink, then the temperature rise within an RA would be significantly less for a given configuration than if the mine does not behave as an infinite heat sink.
- Does the facility in which the test is conducted impact the resulting temperature rise?
- Will the moisture generated by the occupants reduce the air temperature within the RA?
- Could occupancy derating values be used for RAs that are rated and approved for use at one mine ambient temperature, but are deployed in a mine with a higher ambient temperature?
Experimental and analytical studies, described in this report, were designed to answer these questions. Each of the studies contributed incrementally to the overall understanding of the problem, and the knowledge gained in one step was applied in the next to further the understanding of temperature rise in RAs. A recently completed “capstone” study provided data to answer the research questions and to validate the numerical model developed in the project. The four research questions were addressed and answers are presented in this report.
Authors: DS Yantek
Report of Investigations - March 2014
NIOSHTIC2 Number: 20043881
Pittsburgh, PA: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2014-117, (RI 9695), 2014 Mar; :1-63
- Advancement of Refuge Alternatives for Underground Coal Mines
- Announcing Two New Sister Publications on Refuge Alternatives
- Atmospheric Analysis of Refuge Alternatives
- The Challenge of Enforcing Safety Rules in Remote Hazardous Work Areas
- Facilitating the Use of Built-in-place Refuge Alternatives in Mines
- Investigation of Purging and Airlock Contamination of Mobile Refuge Alternatives
- Man Mountain’s Refuge: Refuge Chamber Training Instructor’s Guide and Trainee’s Problem Book
- Medium Frequency Radio System Modifications for Refuge Chamber Situational Awareness
- Refuge Alternatives in Underground Coal Mines
- Refuge Chambers
- Research Report on Refuge Alternatives for Underground Coal Mines
- Update on Refuge Alternatives: Research, Recommendations, and Underground Deployment
- Content source: National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Mining Program