Skip navigation
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
 CDC Home Search Health Topics A-Z
Prevention Among Injection Drug Users
 IDU HIV Prevention

Archive archive

 IDU Home
 Fact Sheets:
 Syringe Disinfection
 Sterile Syringes
 Viral Hepatitis
 Subst. Abuse
Treatment
 Criminal Justice
 Order Printed Materials
 Dear Colleague Letters
 Other Publications
 Comprehensive
Approach
 Brochure
 Document
 Safe Community Syringe Disposal
Explore IDU Topics
Comments
  Legend
Link to a PDF document Link to a PDF document
Link to a Non-CDC site
Link to non-CDC site or document and does not necessarily represent the views of CDC
Adobe Acrobat (TM) Reader needs to be installed on your computer in order to read documents in PDF format. Download the Reader.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

Archival Content: 1999-2005

HIV Prevention Among Drug Users:
A Resource Book for Community Planners & Program Managers


Using the Results of Evaluation Research

The purpose of this section is to provide HIV prevention planners and program managers with results of evaluation research on the general characteristics of effective HIV prevention programs and, more specifically, on interventions that have been shown to be effective at reducing sexual and drug-use risk behaviors among drug-using populations. A mounting body of scientific evidence generated from evaluation research has shown that lasting changes in risky behavior can occur as a result of well-designed interventions.


General Characteristics of Effective Prevention Programs

Behavioral science research has been used to design effective prevention programs in areas such as teen pregnancy, smoking cessation, and substance abuse, as well as in HIV prevention. The results of this research, including that of HIV researchers, (Holtgrave et al., 1995; Choi et al., 1994; Kelly, 1992; Stryker et al., 1995; Janz et al., 1996) has helped identify some general characteristics of effective HIV prevention programs to consider during program design. The more characteristics an intervention integrates into a program, the stronger the chance for effectiveness. Exhibit I below presents these characteristics.


Exhibit I: Effective HIV Prevention Programs

Behavioral research has identified these characteristics of effective programs:
  • are designed according to the results of a comprehensive needs assessment, including an identification of target group members' level of motivation to change risk behaviors
  • are affordable and easy to access by the target population served and are able to respond to other expressed needs of the community
  • are culturally competent, relevant to the targeted population (i.e., consistent with norms, attitudes, and beliefs), and include members of the target population in program planning and implementation
  • have clearly defined target group(s), interventions and program components, and objectives
  • focus on behavioral skills, which include how to carry out low-risk, safer behaviors as well as how to avoid and cope with high-risk situations
  • do not provide messages that are judgmental, moralistic, or attempt to instill fear
  • have ample duration and intensity to achieve lasting behavior change, and provide support and skills necessary to cope with lapses and setbacks in maintaining safe behaviors
  • address the social and community norms of the target population so that program participants receive consistent messages and reinforcement for the prescribed behavior change
  • are offered to the target group as part of a continuum of health care (e.g., drug and alcohol treatment, STD treatment, family planning, other health services)
  • address other basic needs of the targeted population (e.g., housing, food) in order for HIV prevention to be considered a priority
  • are regularly monitored to assure implementation is according to plan and that outcomes are being met

Studies That Evaluate the Effectiveness of HIV Prevention Interventions for Drug Users

In addition to findings about the general characteristics of effective programs, a body of research exists that examines the effectiveness of specific interventions conducted with drug users and their partners. This section provides an overview of selected evaluation studies from the peer-reviewed literature and more general resource materials (books, monographs, journal articles) chosen for their focus on effectiveness and their usefulness to community planners and program managers. More complete descriptions of the materials are contained in Appendices A and B of this document.

Appendix A contains summaries of 13 evaluation studies of interventions selected from the peer-reviewed journal literature. Each has been summarized using a standard Evaluation Study Summary Form designed to address the needs of prevention planners. Nine of the summaries are also included in the document, What Intervention Studies Say About Effectiveness: A Resource for HIV Prevention Community Planning Groups (AED, 1996). Four more have been added to take advantage of new findings and ensure a variety of settings and drug-using populations. These summaries do not represent all studies on intervention effectiveness with drug users. Rather, they are intended to provide a range of current and quality research relevant to the needs of HIV prevention planners and program managers.

Below, Table 3.4 provides a guide to the Evaluation Study Summaries included in Appendix A. The table lists the citation, target populations, and type of intervention for each article included.

Appendix B contains descriptions of additional resources with a focus on effectiveness, including books, book chapters, monographs, and journal articles. These materials offer a broad range of comprehensive information on interventions for drug users and their partners. For example, one book discusses the effectiveness of a range of interventions conducted with drug users and their sex partners (Sorensen, 1991). A chapter in another book addresses interventions conducted with drug users in natural settings (as opposed to drug treatment settings) and their effectiveness (Watters, in DiClemente et al., 1994). A second chapter discusses the effectiveness of interventions for sex partners of HIV-infected or high-risk individuals, with special attention given to partner notification and HIV antibody testing and counseling programs (Padian, in DiClemente et al., 1994). Another important resource is the National Research Council's Congressionally-commissioned national study on the effectiveness of needle exchange and bleach distribution programs (Normand et al., 1995).

Table 3.4: Guide to Evaluation Study Summaries

Article Citation

Target Population

Type of Intervention
Calsyn et al., 1992 Male IDUs Institutional-based (outpatient drug abuse treatment), condom distribution and instruction

Des Jarlais et al., 1992 Adult intranasal heroin users Group-level, peer-mediated counseling

El-Bassel et al., 1995 Adult women with history of drug use Institutional-based (prison), group-level, non-peer mediated counseling

Latkin et al., 1996 Networks of IDUs Group-level, peer-mediated training

Malow et al., 1994 Male African American IDUs and cocaine users Institutional-based (inpatient drug abuse treatment), group-level counseling, non-peer mediated training

Nyamathi et al., 1994 Hispanic women who are homeless and drug-using Group-level counseling, peer-mediated training

Reitmeijer et al., 1996 IDUs Community-level, peer and non-peer street and community outreach

St. Lawrence et al., 1995 Substance dependent adolescents Group-level, non-peer mediated skill training

Schilling et al., 1991 African American and Hispanic female drug users Group-level counseling, non-peer mediated in methadone maintenance program

Siegal et al., 1995 Out-of-treatment, HIV seronegative IDUs Individual and group-level counseling, non-peer mediated

Sorensen et al., 1994 Adult IDUs Community and street outreach, group-level, non-peer mediated counseling in outpatient treatment program

Stephens et al., 1991 Out-of-treatment IDUs Individual-level counseling, non-peer mediated

Watters et al., 1994 Active IDUs Community and street outreach, syringe exchange

 

View PDFPDF Icon

This CDC Web site is no longer being reviewed or updated and thus is no longer kept current. This site remains to assist researchers or others needing historical content.

   
Go to top

Privacy Policy | Accessibility

USA.gov: The U.S. Government's Official Web Portal