Archival Content: 1999-2005
Expectations about the results of substance abuse treatment are often unrealistically high. Greater knowledge about the nature of addiction and the effectiveness of substance abuse treatment can help temper these expectations and lead to a better understanding of the benefits of treatment.
Expectations for Substance Abuse Treatment Often Clash with Reality
Expectations are high.
Many people, including drug users themselves, have mistaken beliefs about drug addiction and recovery from addiction. Two of the most pervasive myths are that "a person can get off drugs alone" and that "most addicts can become permanently drug-free." These ideas stem in part from notions that continued drug use is voluntary and that a person's inability to overcome addiction stems solely from character flaws or a lack of willpower.
Society has differing standards of success for treating chronic conditions or nicotine or alcohol addictions than for treating addiction to injection drugs.
The highly addictive nature of nicotine and the difficulties associated with quitting smoking cigarettes are well understood and accepted. Quitting smoking often requires repeated attempts and the help of therapeutic aids, ranging from nicotine patches and gum to antidepressants, hypnotism, and acupuncture. Only 3-7% of those who try to quit on their own each year succeed. Little stigma is attached to a relapse to smoking. Rather, smokers are urged to try again to quit. The public also has a more evolved understanding of alcoholism as a disease and more realistic expectations about the success of treatment. The potential for relapse after treatment for alcoholism is generally recognized and accepted. In contrast, societal reactions when a person relapses to injection drug use are usually highly negative.
Similarly, society understands that chronic conditions, such as diabetes or high blood pressure, cannot be "cured," but only treated and controlled over many years to reduce potentially severe consequences. In contrast, it is widely believed that it should be possible to permanently cure a person of addiction to injection or other drugs. If a "cure" doesn't happen, then treatment is seen as useless and not deserving of societal investment or support.
Reality does not often meet these expectations.
Numerous studies have shown that it is very hard for injection drug users (IDUs) and others addicted to drugs like cocaine to quit on their own. Research has also shown that relapse to drug use is common and that it is difficult for IDUs and those addicted to other drugs to attain a permanent drug-free state, even after treatment. Many people with addiction problems also have mental health disorders and this makes recovery even more difficult.
Research has provided some explanations for this gap.
A more sophisticated understanding of addiction has emerged in the last two decades and this is helping to clarify the disconnect between expectations and reality:
What Are Some Realistic Expectations for Substance Abuse Treatment?
Research has shown that comprehensive and sustained substance abuse treatment:
Research has also demonstrated that a variety of effective approaches to substance abuse treatment exist that can help people achieve long-term control. This control allows people to reach important goals, including reduced drug use, reduced criminal activity, gainful employment, and more stable life situations.
Extensive experience has revealed a number of issues that are key to successful substance abuse treatment:
To Learn More About This Topic
Read the overview fact sheet in this series on drug users and substance abuse treatment - "Substance Abuse Treatment for Injection Drug Users: A Strategy with Many Benefits." It provides basic information, links to the other fact sheets in this series, and links to other useful information (both print and web).
Check out these sources of information:
Appel PW, Joseph H, Kott A, et al. Selected in-treatment outcomes of long-term methadone maintenance treatment patients in New York State. Mt. Sinai Journal of Medicine 2001;68(1):55-61.
Kwiatkowski CF, Booth RE. Methadone maintenance as HIV risk reduction with street-recruited injecting drug users. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 2001;26(5):483-489.
Leshner A. Addiction is a brain disease. Issues in Science and Technology 2001;17(3).
McLellan AT, Woody GE, Metzger D, et al. Evaluating the effectiveness of addiction treatments: reasonable expectations, appropriate comparisons. Milbank Quarterly 1996;74(1):51-85.
National Institutes of Health. Effective medical treatment of opiate addiction. NIH Consensus Statement Online. Bethesda (MD): NIH; 1997, Nov 17-19;15(6):1-38.
National Institute on Drug Abuse. Principles of drug addiction treatment: a research-based guide. Rockville (MD): NIDA; 1999. NIH Publication No. 99-4180.
This CDC Web site is no longer being reviewed or updated and thus is no longer kept current. This site remains to assist researchers or others needing historical content.